shape
carat
color
clarity

Diamond advice please help!!

Tomdiamond

Rough_Rock
Joined
Jun 14, 2020
Messages
66
Looking for some advice


Blue nile confirmed both the 1.06 and the 1.05 are both NO brown, no green no milky. BOTH ARE EYE CLEAN ALSO

1.06 video
https://d21g74glrkyyov.cloudfront.net/FM411535/FM411535.html
Do you think that this looks milky hazy or grainy? The cut gets a better score on HCA 0.9 but to me it looks like it’s not as see through and the black arrows not as dark or pronounced as the 1.05. Also this has NO FLOUR. Gia states in comments ‘additional clouds, surface graining and pinpoints not shown’. If you spin the diamond on pic you can definately see the pinpoints/graining or maybe clouds?

1.05 video.
https://www.bluenile.com/uk/diamond-details/LD13560253

Is £250 more expensive. This has been confirmed as no BGM. This gets 2.2 HCA score but the arrows look darker and more pronounced (is this just the camera). The gia comment is ‘clouds not shown’

If price difference isn’t a factor then in ur opinion what is the best diamond?

Again this is a difficult one as 2 different vaults taking picture with a different background and on diamond on side while the other is horizontal so I think this could also have a impact on how this diamond looks on the videos when comparing with each other
 

Attachments

Looking for some advice


Blue nile confirmed both the 1.06 and the 1.05 are both NO brown, no green no milky.

1.06 video
https://d21g74glrkyyov.cloudfront.net/FM411535/FM411535.html
Do you think that this looks milky hazy or grainy? The cut gets a better score on HCA 0.9 but to me it looks like it’s not as see through and the black arrows not as dark or pronounced as the 1.05. Also this has NO FLOUR. Gia states in comments ‘additional clouds, surface graining and pinpoints not shown’. If you spin the diamond on pic you can definately see the pinpoints/graining or maybe clouds?

1.05 video.
https://www.bluenile.com/uk/diamond-details/LD13560253

Is £250 more expensive. This has been confirmed as no BGM. This gets 2.2 HCA score but the arrows look darker and more pronounced (is this just the camera). The gia comment is ‘clouds not shown’

If price difference isn’t a factor then in ur opinion what is the best diamond?

Again this is a difficult one as 2 different vaults taking picture with a different background and on diamond on side while the other is horizontal so I think this could also have a impact on how this diamond looks on the videos when comparing with each other

Both are EYE CLEAN ALSO
 
Most people dont like to download links...could you post the certs? Or give links to the stones/certs?
 
Most people dont like to download links...could you post the certs? Or give links to the stones/certs?

Hi, no problem.

1.05 is

https://www.bluenile.com/uk/diamond-details/LD13560253

and 1.06 is

https://www.bluenile.com/uk/build-your-own-ring/diamond-details/LD13918937


1.06 video in original post.

Just got more info back from blue nile. They advised the 1.06 had a SLIGHT BROWN TINGE, eye clean and no green or milky. While the 1.05 is eye clean no bgm. Does that affect your desision? Setting is plat
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top