Deciding between 3 stones

[diamondgirl3]

Hello!

I am deciding between three stones, and would love some input:

1)2.19 Carat Round Brilliant Diamond
Diamond Jewelry Laboratory Cert (DGL)
Clarity: SI1
Color: H
Measurements: 8.66-8.73x5.03mm
Depth: 56.8%
Table: 57.3%
Polish: Good
Symmetry: Good
Fluorescence: None
Cutlet: None
Price: $10,500

2)2.02 Carat Round Brilliant Diamond
EGL Cert
Clarity: VS1
Color: H
Measurements: 8.12-8.15x4.96mm
Depth: 61.0%
Table: 58.0%
Polish: Good
Symmetry: Very Good
Fluorescence: None
Cutlet: None
Price: $10,200

3) 2.0 Carat Round Brilliant Diamond
EGL Cert
Clarity: Si1
Color: H
Depth: 61.6%
Table: 58%
Polish: Good
Symmetry: Good
Cutlet: None
Price: $9,900

I am leaning towards #1, but need advice on the cut and feelings on the DGL cert. The stone I choose will be going into a four prong platinum Tiffany style setting.

Thanks!

 

[noobie]

Have you seen the diamonds? Is the vendor reputable? Those prices seem almost too good to be true and certainly lower for quality stones that are the grades that these are represented to be.

 

[diamondgirl3]

I haven't seen them in person yet, but both companies have a great no hassle return policy. I'm more concerned about the quality of #1 more than anything. Anyone have any thoughts on this?

 

[researcher]

I've never heard of the cert for #1. Although I know virtually nothing about rounds, my gut says #2.

 

[diamondgirl3]

Will the fact that the table is greater than the depth make stone #1 look incredibly dull, or just slightly?