shape
carat
color
clarity

Cushion Cut Diamond - Table % Concern / Money's worth?

Boston22

Rough_Rock
Joined
Apr 22, 2012
Messages
3
Hey all,

So I've done a lot of research on my own about cushion cut diamonds and I've met with several jewelers over the past 6 months or so. I found the jeweler I want to work with and she gathered up about 12 square cushions (non-crushed ice look) for me to look at. There was one that just stood out among the rest on display; however, it had a unique characteristic that I wasn't used to seeing. The table was larger than the depth of the stone. In most of my searching, I've tried to find a table around the mid 50s with depth mid 60s. This table however is 72% and 65% depth.

The stone is running $15,400 and I've attached the GIA cert. I know its likely tough to tell without seeing the stone, but it has a very unique look to it (in a good way).

My only hesitation is that the price either 1) shouldn't be that high if the large table = bad cut or 2) it doesn't fully light up like a fireball in direct sunlight. There's a lot of sparkle, but the fire is more around the corners/edges.

Any opinions help as I need to make a decision tomorrow. Also - my g/f was with me when we looked at the diamonds and this one was hands down her favorite. She loves it which is great, but can I do better for the money too? And are there any other concerns from looking at the GIA mapping?

Thanks!

-Brian
 

Attachments

Any comments are greatly appreciated.

Some more facts on the stone without looking at the GIA cert attached above.

Carat: 1.76
Color: E
Clarity: SI1
Fluorescence: None
 
You are the one that saw the ston but off the GIA report I probably wouldn't buy it. The inclusions scare me - where they are positioned and how many there are. Further, I would think that facet pattern would give a crushed ice look.

What were the other options shown to you?
 
There is not enough information to comment, certs are not enough when evaluating cushions.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top