shape
carat
color
clarity

Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rings..

Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

It's been fun reading everyone's thoughts and feelings on the subject!

I still have my original ER from DH, I didn't keep it because I had any sentimental attachment to it, but because I purchased pre PS and didn't have an upgrade or trade in policy. I'm happy today that I still have it because it is the first ring that DH ever bought me, and I think that is meaningful to my son who tells me that one day he wants it to give to his future bride. Though I hope that he changes his mind and decides to purchase something of a better quality when the times come, it's means a lot to me that he wants the ring and that makes me very happy that I kept it.

It's been said here that the ring doesn't define the relationship and while I agree, I understand that perhaps it does on some level to some people. Some people look for colorless and flawless to represent the person for whom it is purchased or the relationship itself, or they use birthstones to denote special events in their lives together, monograms etc. And I suppose that for some the size of the stone is supposed to be representative of the love that they have for that person. So, I get how a ring could become especially meaningful to a couple or more meaningful to one of the people in the relationship than the other. But for me it's the symbolism of the rings that I'm attracted to not so very much the rings themselves. I love that my rings mean that I'm married to an incredible man who loves me every bit as much as I love him, that I have the most fantastic family and that we are in it together until the end of time. I love that when I look down at my hand that I think of how fortunate I am to have found the most perfect partner and how happy we still make each other. These feelings obviously aren't a result of the rings themselves and they won't go away if I upgrade or heaven forbid lose my rings tomorrow. The feelings are a result of the relationship itself, I feel the same way when I wear my original ering as I do when I wear my upgraded a few times ering. People change, styles change, finances change, even your relationship will change, and there is something very meaningful to me when I look back at the ring we started with and then look at the one we currently have....I can see the journey and it makes me smile to think about how far we have come.
 
Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

I am getting a 2 carat upgrade in September. We considered selling my old set....I don't have emotional attachment to diamonds- they are hunks of carbon. BUT...I have a marquis-which is not very desirable for re-sale. BUT it is a D color, VS1 or 2? and a gorgeous sparkly white well cut stone.. So because our good friend is a well-respected custom jewelry maker, we decided to just make it into something I could wear. I had it made into a cocktail ring and a wedding band that would match my new E-ring. Otherwise, I would have gotten peanuts for my marquis.... here are before and after pics to give you an idea of what you could do..

img_1281.jpg

img_1282.jpg
 
Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

I just went through this decision. I was engaged at 20, with a large diamond (1.68). I had never heard of upgrading (until 3 years later when my MIL upgraded to 3 ct because mine was bigger than her original). I considered selling my stone for an upgrade, but for several sentimental reasons, realized I would miss it. After wearing my original solitaire for 28 years, not much was left of the setting (due to repairs), but I had another head put on it for a temp setting for my new 4.3 OEC. I am planning to use my 1.68 and some other stones to make a pendant that I will wear most days. My husband doesn't care about the upgrade, but he didn't like the idea of selling the original. I only have one daughter, so someday she will hit the jackpot.
 
Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

I traded in my round brilliant for a larger round brilliant. For my next upgrade, it will probably be an EC, but I think I will keep the round just to have some variety. I did keep the wedding ring and the old setting as I feel they have sentimental value.
 
Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

I will keep my current rings when I upgrade. One ring was given when he proposed, the other when we married. I would only sell them if we needed the money for the upgrade, which I don't foresee happening (but you can't predict the future of course).

I should add that I'm not a frequent upgrader, won't be doing so until our fifth anniversary at least. I'm very happy with my rings right now. Actually, any new rings i get should probably be called anniversary rings and not upgrades really.
 
Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

I just upgraded and also kept my original e-ring. My reasons for upgrading were because I wanted something bigger, and not because my original was no longer my style or that I had fallen out of love with it. I still love and adore it, and still choose to wear it sometimes instead of my new honker.
 
Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

star sparkle|1372872032|3476700 said:
I just upgraded and also kept my original e-ring. My reasons for upgrading were because I wanted something bigger, and not because my original was no longer my style or that I had fallen out of love with it. I still love and adore it, and still choose to wear it sometimes instead of my new honker.


And your new honker is amazing. :love: But I love your sweet fishtail set too. Its always been a favorite of mine.
 
Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

bastetcat|1372874710|3476741 said:
star sparkle|1372872032|3476700 said:
I just upgraded and also kept my original e-ring. My reasons for upgrading were because I wanted something bigger, and not because my original was no longer my style or that I had fallen out of love with it. I still love and adore it, and still choose to wear it sometimes instead of my new honker.


And your new honker is amazing. :love: But I love your sweet fishtail set too. Its always been a favorite of mine.

Aww, thanks, you're too kind!! As you can see, I still haven't been able to bear replacing my avatar photo with the new honker, so that must say something about how much I just love my original ering! :lol:
 
Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

A timely thread as I am currently researching into upgrading my 0.5 ct RB to something more like a 1 ct RB for my 10th anniversary next year. I intend to make my existing 0.5 ct stone into a pendant that will become a family heirloom and be passed to my daughter when she turns 18.
 
Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

If I upgraded I'd keep the original. We got engaged when he was 20, and we were on what I would consider to be a small budget. Our second-hand ring has had tons of issues with it and has been repaired a couple times and needs more work done to it. It's had a lot of issues and I can't imagine that it's worth much.

I agree with the man who said that it may be a generational thing. I'm in my early 30's and have only had my ring for 9 years. It was bought before PS and is roughly the same quality and size that I see on people in my husband's peer group. DH believes that after people have been married for a bit, they quit wearing their engagement rings and just wear their bands so he doesn't really understand why I might want something else. So far, I've proved him right, but it's because I don't particularly like my ring. I didn't wear it through out my engagement unless I felt it was the correct thing to do - such as when the two of us went out to dinner. I do feel sorry for the poor thing and try to wear it more. Upgrading is also not the done thing here.

If we'd been a bit older or had a larger budget or researched diamonds more then I might think more like you do about upgrades. However, if I'm ever lucky enough to get another ring I would keep my original...it wouldn't sell for much so I can't see getting rid of it for a pittance. I do feel sorry for it and find myself odd attached to it.
 
Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

Rhea|1373025520|3477563 said:
I agree with the man who said that it may be a generational thing. I'm in my early 30's and have only had my ring for 9 years. It was bought before PS and is roughly the same quality and size that I see on people in my husband's peer group. DH believes that after people have been married for a bit, they quit wearing their engagement rings and just wear their bands so he doesn't really understand why I might want something else. So far, I've proved him right, but it's because I don't particularly like my ring. I didn't wear it through out my engagement unless I felt it was the correct thing to do - such as when the two of us went out to dinner. I do feel sorry for the poor thing and try to wear it more. Upgrading is also not the done thing here.

If we'd been a bit older or had a larger budget or researched diamonds more then I might think more like you do about upgrades. However, if I'm ever lucky enough to get another ring I would keep my original...it wouldn't sell for much so I can't see getting rid of it for a pittance. I do feel sorry for it and find myself odd attached to it.

Funny Cause I'm in my early 30's too. I think its awesome that you have been married for 9 years. The only reason I'm not jealous is because waiting allowed me to meet my FI!

Emotional attachment to "things" is always such a personal issue. THe fact that you don't like your original ER but try and show it some love is cool. But it would be also cool to want to get something you would wear every day. The answers to thes questions are as diverse as the people on this board. There isn't a wrong one.
 
Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

BP, he had just turned 22 when we married, and bought the ring when we was 20. Late 20s to early 30s (he's s bit younger than I am) feels early to want a change. I kinda can't believe the ring its about to celebrate its 9th anniversary. Life changed a lot between 20 and now for us in terms of what we wanted. I think at 20 we were just happy to be together and the ring was what we could afford.

DH and I are going to a lot of weddings this year as all his friends get married. DH remarked last night that he's "over weddings... no one will remember the details anyway ”...we were discussing what, if any, flowers the latest couple had. We are finding it quite odd to be in our late 20s and very early 30s and be this out from our peer group in terms of engagement and marriage. And DH is finding it hard to go with the wishes of the grooms and not say "quit stressing about the cuff links, no one remembers anyhow." :)
 
Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

Rhea|1373031732|3477594 said:
DH and I are going to a lot of weddings this year as all his friends get married. DH remarked last night that he's "over weddings... no one will remember the details anyway ”...we were discussing what, if any, flowers the latest couple had. We are finding it quite odd to be in our late 20s and very early 30s and be this out from our peer group in terms of engagement and marriage. And DH is finding it hard to go with the wishes of the grooms and not say "quit stressing about the cuff links, no one remembers anyhow." :)

Tell him to say it! I feel like this and we haven't even started planning! I want simple and no fuss. But alas that is not the reality we will face.

Sorry for the threadjack.
 
Re: Curious for those of you who upgrade/have upgraded e-rin

I still have mine and wouldn't part with it. I upgraded after 16 years then again twice in our 20th year.

My original ering and wedding ring has a gemstone in it now and the original diamond (.15 ct) is in an open heart pendant that I wear quite a bit. Our original wedding bands I am probably going to have melted down in to a gold band to wear with my ering sometimes.

I have sentiment attached to my original because DH picked it out for me. My upgrades were something we picked together and have no sentimental value so I have no problem saying "honey can I get anew ring or a new diamond".
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top