I have some questions about setting a loose diamond, and I don't know much or really anything about this, so I was hoping someone knowledgeable might be able to help me out. I purchased a 1 carat pear diamond on blue nile, but blue nile doesn't have the setting my girlfriend wants on their website. The setting she likes is at Shaneco. Shaneco wanted $3,000 more for a comparable diamond (just going off the 4C's) and theirs didn't come with a gia report . Shaneco did clarify that a gia report doesn't really mean anything because it's just one person's opinion, and their appraisers are all gia certified, but at the end of the day their prices were much higher so I went with Blue nile for a diamond (after I purchased the blue nile diamond, shaneco said they'd try and me find a better deal, tbd). I would note that shaneco was nice to us, and they spent 3 hours educating us on diamonds, whereas at blue niles "custom order" line the person was a bit condescending and acted like he'd rather be doing something else than discussing a custom setting quote for me (haven't received their custom quote yet, also tbd).
I called 4 shanecos and received 3 different quotes for the cost to set my loose 1 carat diamond on their setting. The cost was all based on a dollar amount per point, plus the shape of the diamond, ranging from $3.00 to $4.50. I also emailed their online customer support and was told the prices average $3 a point for a pear diamond. The farther south the shaneco I called, the higher the price. I went to a $3.00/per point store, they have their own jeweler in house, who you can watch do his work, so maybe that's why they're cheaper.
1. Is $300 to set my diamond reasonable? It seems high, but Shaneco has a lifetime warranty if you use their jeweler, also they've been nice to us.
2. The setting my girlfriend likes only has three 3 prongs to hold a 1 carat diamond. Being OCD by nature, I thought that seemed low, so I asked for two additional prongs, so 5 prongs total, and they said it'll be an additional $75. Is that fair? The diamond is already insured through jewelers mutual, but i really don't want to lose it. The setting is white gold, 14K.
3. Last question, the "head" of the setting is a halo, and has a peg base. The setting is sort of a tapered cathedral type setting, and the only attachment of the head to the ring is the peg base. Is this secure? Blue nile (if i get a custom setting from them) they would bridge the gap, between the cathedral tips and the head, so that there'd be three areas of attachment to the ring. But my girlfriend doesn't like that look. She wants a floating look. Is the floating single point of contact (the peg base) is that secure?
I called 4 shanecos and received 3 different quotes for the cost to set my loose 1 carat diamond on their setting. The cost was all based on a dollar amount per point, plus the shape of the diamond, ranging from $3.00 to $4.50. I also emailed their online customer support and was told the prices average $3 a point for a pear diamond. The farther south the shaneco I called, the higher the price. I went to a $3.00/per point store, they have their own jeweler in house, who you can watch do his work, so maybe that's why they're cheaper.
1. Is $300 to set my diamond reasonable? It seems high, but Shaneco has a lifetime warranty if you use their jeweler, also they've been nice to us.
2. The setting my girlfriend likes only has three 3 prongs to hold a 1 carat diamond. Being OCD by nature, I thought that seemed low, so I asked for two additional prongs, so 5 prongs total, and they said it'll be an additional $75. Is that fair? The diamond is already insured through jewelers mutual, but i really don't want to lose it. The setting is white gold, 14K.
3. Last question, the "head" of the setting is a halo, and has a peg base. The setting is sort of a tapered cathedral type setting, and the only attachment of the head to the ring is the peg base. Is this secure? Blue nile (if i get a custom setting from them) they would bridge the gap, between the cathedral tips and the head, so that there'd be three areas of attachment to the ring. But my girlfriend doesn't like that look. She wants a floating look. Is the floating single point of contact (the peg base) is that secure?