shape
carat
color
clarity

Comparing two diamonds

zorrikina

Rough_Rock
Joined
Nov 28, 2015
Messages
4
Hi, I'm trying to decide between two diamonds for an engagement ring for my beautiful girlfriend. I was hoping you could help me make my final decision.

Diamond #1
2.35 carat, I, VS1, Strong Blue Fluorescence
table 57%, depth 61.8%, crown angle 35.5, crown% 15.5, pavilion angle 40.8, pavilion% 43, star length 50%, lower half percentage 80%
$15,300

7681462_-_real.jpg
7681462_-_idealscope.jpg7681462_-_aset.jpg

Diamond #2
2.12, J, VS1, No Fluorescence
table 58%, depth 60.7%, crown angle 33, crown% 13.5, pavilion angle 41.0, pavilion% 43.5, star length 45%, lower half percentage 75%
$14,200

7532243_real.jpg7532243_idealscope.jpg7532243_aset.jpgb2c_stock__7532243__hearts_image_.jpgb2c_stock__7532243__arrows_image_.jpg

Both are GIA triple excellent.

Thanks for all your help!
 
Number 2 please. My address to ship to is…
 
Thanks for the input! I am also wondering if the crown angle is too shallow on diamond #2. And has there been instances when good ASET images do not translate into good looking stones?
 
The first diamond is 2.6 and the second is 0.8 on the HCA scale.
 
Hoooooray #2. No contest.
 
Yep. It will be beautiful in person
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top