Compare These Two Diamonds For Me (Engagement Ring)?

[Dmueller9834]

Below is the current options:

1.) The current diamond is: VS1, Color G, Cut / Symmetry / Polish were good to very good. Size is .72 points (carat)



2.) The new diamond is: VS2, Color F, Cut / Symmetry / Polish were all excellent / ideal. Fluorescence was none on the report. Comes with full GIA report (on hand) and it ranks higher then the other diamond on the rapaport report. Old diamond was a a 41, the new one even while a level lower vs1 to vs2 it ranks at a 42.


Thanks,

Devin

 

[everstone]

Well obviously the second diamond is miles better. Am I missing something?

 

[Dmueller9834]

Gia number 2204694075 for further info, this is for diamond number 2, thought maybe a vs1 to vs2 clarity was a bigger deal. But looks to be cut is better and color is now rare white +

 

[telephone89]

The vs1 and vs2 will be pretty equivalent. The second one is the one I'd go for