by JayLR » May 19, 2017 at 11:26 AM Hello Everyone! I'm new here and excited to see if people with more knowledge and experience can help me out a bit with my first diamond purchase. I am looking for a center stone for an E. Ring and I found one 1.9 carat SI1 (eye clean) stone that is color I which scores a 2.3 on Holloway and I found another 2.04 carat VS2 that is color J, which scores .8 on Holloway. The certs for the two stones can be found here: http://www.levycreations.com/diaCertificates/2151481348.jpg and http://www.levycreations.com/diaCertificates/5236184760.jpg. I'm don't really care about the value or rarity of the stone, I just want the best looking/most sparkly stone to the casual/untrained viewer. So, are either of these stones good? And, is the better Holloway score more significant than the 1 color grade difference? I greatly appreciate any assistance!