shape
carat
color
clarity

Clouds on diamond advice

wylergnu

Rough_Rock
Joined
Nov 14, 2012
Messages
1
Hi, question from a newbie:

Im looking at buying an engagement ring for my partner. We are opening up a small business soon so Im trying to keep it affordable. Shes not real picky about diamonds, the style of ring is probably more of a concern but I know she will want a 1.0 ct diamond (or close to it) to show off.

I have a 1.007 ct ideal I SI2 (eye clean) diamond on hold at Whiteflash to go with a white gold tiffany setting (HCA 1.3):

http://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/round-cut-loose-diamond-2805421.htm

The comments in the AGS Certificate says "the clarity grade of this diamond is based on clouds that are not shown". I understand that if the diamond is eye clean I shouldnt be able to see the clouds, but will this reduce the "sparkle?" at all? I cant even see the clouds on the close up image, yet I can clearly see imperfections on other higher graded clarity diamonds that Ive looked at.

Also, Ive read elsewhere that an AGS colour "I" may be closer to a GIA "J", so Im worried that the diamond may look more yellow that other GIA diamonds Ive viewed here in Australia. In this regard my other preferred diamond is the following 0.993 ct ideal H SI1 diamond (HCA 1.8 ):

http://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/round-cut-loose-diamond-2788969.htm

The size difference wouldnt be notiecable, so I would be paying almost $700 more for one grade better colour and clarity.

Im very new to all this so sorry if these are dumb questions. Whichever diamond I go for I think it will be from Whiteflash as their service has been brilliant so far, even going to the trouble of calling me out of hours due to the time difference.
 
Whiteflash will best be able to advise you about that particular stone.

There are always some I colors that are "closer to J" because color is a continuous scale and certain sections of it are assigned to certain letters.
 
I agree with what JulieN has to say...."Whiteflash will best be able to advise you about that stone."

If I had to choose out of these 2 stones, I would definitely go for an SI1 clarity diamond as SI2 might not be an eye clean diamond. I would ask them to get the stones checked by their gemologist and post that make a decision....

If incase I do not like the diamond, I can always avail the 30 day return policy.

You may Check with them about their terms, return/refund & return shipping policy...
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top