Choosing between two diamonds..please help!

[Radiant R]

2.53
1
D
SI2
GIA
8.22
7.24
5.27
72.8
74
ETN - VTK

or

2.29
G
si1
GIA
8.65x6.67x4.54
table width 70%
Cr Height 12.5
pav depth 54.0

both around the same cost...any thoughts?

 

[belle]

there is not enough information on these to tell anything about them except that the first one is more square than the second.
hopefully you will be able to see them side by side and pick the one that appeals to you more.
best of luck!

 

[Radiant R]

what other information do you need? This is everything that is on the cert.....Thanks.

 

[coda72]

The way you posted the specs makes it a little hard to figure out. Is the depth on the first one 72.8 or is the depth 74? Also, for the second one you have no depth listed, but you have a pavilion depth and crown height listed. Those numbers don''t appear on a GIA report, so where do they come from?