choice between 2

[skeet1862]

The following 2 diamonds are princess cut and GIA graded. Please let me know what you think and help me determine which is the better selection:

Diamond #1 Diamond #2

price $4,736.00 $4,787.00
carat 1.02 1.01
cut VG VG
color H H
clarity VS2 VVS1
depth% 69.3% 69.5%
table% 71% 71%
sym VG VG
polish EX EX
girdle slight thick to thick thin to slight thick
culet none none
flourescence none none
measure 5.59x5.53x3.83mm 5.75x5.51x3.83

Thank you SO much for your insight.

 

[belle]

both are on the shallow side with large tables...i could only guess that the crown is low... not usually a good combination.
have you seen them in person?

 

[Hest88]

Not crazy about either one. If I *had* to choose between just these two it would be #2, but I''d rather be given other choices.