I have a few questions about the price and quality of a diamond I saw today. It is a Canadian "branded" diamond (NWT government certified) with the following specifications:
GIA report:
round brilliant
1 ct
F color
VVS1
depth 60.6%
table 56%
girdle thin-med
polish excellent
symmetry very good
no flourescence
AGS report:
Polish Ideal
Symmetry Ideal
Proportions Ideal
HCA score 1.6 [*]
price: US$9200
1) is there any reason to be concerned that the GIA grades the symmetry as "very good" rather than "excellent"
2)is there any reason to be concerned that the diamond only scored 1 "excellent" on the HCA?
3) is this a good price for this diamond?
Thanks in advance for any opinions and/or advice.
GIA report:
round brilliant
1 ct
F color
VVS1
depth 60.6%
table 56%
girdle thin-med
polish excellent
symmetry very good
no flourescence
AGS report:
Polish Ideal
Symmetry Ideal
Proportions Ideal
HCA score 1.6 [*]
price: US$9200
1) is there any reason to be concerned that the GIA grades the symmetry as "very good" rather than "excellent"
2)is there any reason to be concerned that the diamond only scored 1 "excellent" on the HCA?
3) is this a good price for this diamond?
Thanks in advance for any opinions and/or advice.