Can you please look at these IGI reports? Narrowed it down to three. Please help me with which is best!

[Christa H]

I had no idea looking for a stone would make me so obsessive over looking at them all! I’ve changed my mind and I’m going with an entirely new setting, four prong solitaire. These are the three contenders. Which would you consider the best and why? 1.18 carat is most expensive, 1.02 carat is second, and 1.10 is least. But the total difference is minimal, 200$ between the most expensive and least. They’re all eye clean and I need to decide so they can hold it for me! In this case if they’re all eye clean and well cut do you go for size? Is the 1.18 going to be noticeably larger than the 1.10? I appreciate your time. *im leaning towards the 1.10*

 

[Kim N]

I like the 1.02 and 1.10 equally. If you're leaning towards the 1.10, I'd go for that one! I don't like the 1.18 for a ring because of the low pavilion angle (potential obstruction issues).

 

[Christa H]

I like the 1.02 and 1.10 equally. If you're leaning towards the 1.10, I'd go for that one! I don't like the 1.18 for a ring because of the low pavilion angle (potential obstruction issues).

Thank you.

 

[DejaWiz]

Here's the order in which I like them, based on the grading reports, alone:

3
2
1

 

[Christa H]

Here's the order in which I like them, based on the grading reports, alone:

3
2
1

Thank you! I feel like my choice has been confirmed and I thank you for your help! Now I’m going to stop mindlessly looking at them.