Can you help me pick a diamond for an antique looking pendant?

[Frumasring]

Hi scopers,

im interested in having a 20 inch white gold miligrain bezeled pendant made by diamonds by Lauren. im torn between 2 antique stones, similar sizes but drastically different specs. Can you help me decide which would give me more of that antique feel but still give my joy in wearing daily. I’m not really against the K color in the R9157 stone or the I1 in the R9042 so I’m really just not sure how to pick.
thanks for your advice!

 

[diamondseeker2006]

The I1 looks too included for me. The K looks better overall if you are ok with the color. There are more stones out there than these two, also. I would want to see more options than these.