Can you help me compare these IS and ASET images?

[lookingforever]

Hi again,

I feel like I am posting a ton of questions, but I just have a TON of questions (esp after reading more and more). However, I think I am very close now to choosing a RB.

I have read various threads on reading an ASET and IS but am still not really sure how to compare one from another. I am looking at two diamonds (one which I haven't posted previously on, as i was comparing two other RBs in another thread), and they have similar color and clarity with branded cuts. I guess what I am trying to do now is compare their ASET and IS pics to decide which would be the better performer. Can you please help me compare them and also point out what is that you are seeing so that I can learn more about using the ASET and IS?

Thank you!!

Diamond #1 - 1.242ct I SI1:


Diamond #2 - 1.203ct H SI1

 

[JulieN]

They are very similar.

 

[Andelain]

I like the bottom one a bit better, but they'll both be great.

 

[tyty333]

Are they from the same vendor? Ask to have the gemologist review them and tell you
what they see.

 

[Christina...]

I agree with tyty, if the stones are with the same vendor then I would ask for a side by side comparison.

 

[Daisyoz]

It seems the first diamond is from BG and the second one from Whiteflash. I think the ASET image of the first one is slightly better but I like the look of the second one' Ideal scope. Really you cant go wrong with either. Perhaps other things to consider including prices, colour, size, setting?