shape
carat
color
clarity

Buying insights and Infinity Diamonds

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

f4fred

Rough_Rock
Joined
Apr 3, 2006
Messages
16
Hi All,

Just wanted to throw in my two-cents. I have been on the market for a diamond for a few months and in that period have seen dozens of stones in both B&M stores and via independent appraisers. This was a painful process but for the fact that I stumbled across Infinity Diamonds: http://www.infinitydiamonds.be

I can categorically say that every stone that these guys produce exceeds every other stone that I came across in my search in terms of all round beauty. At risk of sounding like an advert for Infinity, I can not emphasize strongly enough: do not buy your diamond until you have at least seen one of Paul’s Crafted By Infinity diamonds. Wink and others can arrange for you to see them. What is the downside? The upside is having one of the most beautiful stones on the planet.

During my research with Wink and Paul, I had a few ‘ah-ha’ moments as a consumer interested in scaling the learning curve as quickly as possible. I hope you don’t mind me sharing:

• Cut is by far the most important of the characteristics of a diamond. I originally wanted to go with a stone that was flawless but after looking at different stones under the loupe you get nothing more for your money by going IF over VS2. You may feel better about yourself but no one is going to know.
I also thought that size was king and I had expected to see huge differences between 1.5, 1.6, 1.7c diamonds. This is not the case. At arms length, and with a set moving diamond, you won’t be able to tell the difference, at least I wasn’t.
Now color is a tricky one. I really refused to budge from D-F for ages until I saw Paul’s stones. When the cut is non-ideal, especially in Princess stones, the color was really easy to identify. With Infinity’s super-ideal cut, face-up diamonds are neigh-on impossible to tell an F from a G and a G from an H.
Finally, the biggest insight on this front was the cut itself. I saw two 1c stones side-by-side; one was well cut and the other poorly cut. The light leakage that the poorly cut diamond had, at arms length, made that stone look 0.5c smaller!! This is much more important than you killing yourself on whether you can afford to go up 0.1 or 0.2c in weight.

• When you are in a store or at an appraiser, make sure to look at the stones in lots of different lighting conditions. I saw many stones that were beautiful under bright lighting but crawl under the desk and you will see that light and beauty leak away. Better to do this before you give that diamond to your fiancé in dim lighting conditions!! The Infinity RBs that I saw were all beautiful as can be expected under bright conditions, but in my dark corner, it was just amazing to see the brightness shine right to the very edge.

• The market doesn’t seem to charge anything for exactly square Princesses over those that are not square. For me, however, I would pay more to have an exactly square Princess as I love that symmetry – surely something that is inherent with the very idea of cutting diamonds. If you want a source of exactly square diamonds, I needn’t tell you where you need to look!!! All I can say, is that these guys should be charging more.

• H&A may mean a really well-cut stone but this alone does not guarantee great light performance. I only researched H&A stones and the variation between the performances is unimaginably large. The particular dimensions of the facets in combination with the H&A pattern is what is important. Do not just assume that buying an H&A means you will have an amazing stone.

• There are lots of Brands kicking around and I was and still am skeptical about their value to consumers. What are you really buying? Are you just falling into a marketing trap? I even thought this may have been the case with Infinity diamonds as well until I saw a whole range of RBs and Princesses. The thing that you get with their brand is unbelievable consistency across every stone that they produce – and they publish immense amount of data on each as well. Ask Wink, but I would never ever ever ever buy a $$$ stone without seeing it first. This involved shipping stones to and from my appraiser and me having to take time out to check ‘em over. Hand on heart, I am now comfortable buying any Infinity cut stone sight-unseen. That is the value of their brand to the consumer; extremely high quality control.

• Infinity, via their dealers, offer a trade-up policy. If you ever want to upgrade to a larger stone, they will buy back the original. Think about how valuable that is to you. That option value may just save your life and your wallet.

• People talk about buying over the internet and that being a really risky thing to do as well as being very unromantic. Hmm… my experience was not so. I spoke extensively to Wink by phone garnering his brilliant expertise and then was fortunate enough to meet Paul, a true genius in the business. Buying my Infinity stone was one of the lowest-risk purchases of my life… as long as she says yes!!!

Sorry for the long ramble but I thought my experiences may help others just as Pricescope really helped me find Wink, Paul and my perfect diamond.

Ciao
 

WinkHPD

Ideal_Rock
Trade
Joined
May 3, 2001
Messages
7,516
Thank you for your many kind words. You were a lot of fun to work with, and I must admit that very few of our clients are willing to travel to Antwerp to sit with Paul to make sure you are seeing all of the stones you wish to see.

After all of your efforts, I certainly hope that she does say yes!

Wink
 

belle

Super_Ideal_Rock
Joined
Nov 19, 2004
Messages
10,285
you have seen the light!
35.gif


thanks for taking the time to put down your thoughts f4fred, i hope you will stick around and share your valuable insights with others.
 

strmrdr

Super_Ideal_Rock
Joined
Nov 1, 2003
Messages
23,295
wow
congrates!

How awesome to be able to travel to Antwerp and meet with Paul.
Please tell us about your meeting :}

You are right Paul cuts some of the best diamonds in the world.
You are also right that some brands are worth it and some not.

Im glad that Wink and Paul were able to serve you well.

What did you end up getting? pictures?
 

aljdewey

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Nov 25, 2002
Messages
9,170
Congrats! It''s great to hear such warm review for the Infinity line. I hear great things about it!
 

Dancing Fire

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Apr 3, 2004
Messages
33,852
Infinity recut my wife''s stone with help through Wink.you can''t go wrong with these two gent''s.
36.gif
36.gif
 

f4fred

Rough_Rock
Joined
Apr 3, 2006
Messages
16
I ended up going for a 1.57 H VS1 RB which I am having set in a Vatche Royal Crown style
28.gif


Paul not only gave me his expert answers to my diamond related questions, he put up with my indecision on choosing between three beautiful stones and then he showed me round the old diamond district of Antwerp.

I''ll be sure to post a picture and/or video of the ring once I have it back

Thanks once more, not only to Wink and Paul, but also to everyone here on Pricescope who have provided excellent advice, lots of
34.gif
for my secret project, and a new found ability to generate worried looks on the faces of B&M jewlers!
 

^

Rough_Rock
Joined
May 9, 2006
Messages
91
Thanks for the feedback on your experience. I looked around their site somewhat and am not as blown away by their selection as I was expecting. For instance:

.904 AGS0 F IF
http://www.infinitydiamonds.be/diamond.php?ID=100
http://www.elmyrservices.net/stonepreview.php?id=fb80ff014a0e245dc7cceeb6c0a51fba&cid=2
Click on Visagem Page 2

The H&A image is not great. The Idealscope image is not great either, in my amateur opinion. Do others agree? I know you said that perfect H&A doesn''t promise a good stone, and that''s true. But for you to "categorically say that every stone that these guys produce exceeds every other stone" is a pretty strong statement, and I''ve seen far better Idealscope images elsewhere. Maybe Paul showed you the best that he had, and it was your impression that all Infinity stones were of that caliber?

Not trying to threadcrxx, just trying to keep the dialog open. I''m still at the beginning of my secret project.
41.gif


^
 

belle

Super_Ideal_Rock
Joined
Nov 19, 2004
Messages
10,285
Date: 5/22/2006 8:38:50 PM
Author: ^
Thanks for the feedback on your experience. I looked around their site somewhat and am not as blown away by their selection as I was expecting. For instance:

.904 AGS0 F IF
http://www.infinitydiamonds.be/diamond.php?ID=100
http://www.elmyrservices.net/stonepreview.php?id=fb80ff014a0e245dc7cceeb6c0a51fba&cid=2
Click on Visagem Page 2

The H&A image is not great. The Idealscope image is not great either, in my amateur opinion. Do others agree? I know you said that perfect H&A doesn''t promise a good stone, and that''s true. But for you to ''categorically say that every stone that these guys produce exceeds every other stone'' is a pretty strong statement, and I''ve seen far better Idealscope images elsewhere. Maybe Paul showed you the best that he had, and it was your impression that all Infinity stones were of that caliber?

Not trying to threadcrxx, just trying to keep the dialog open. I''m still at the beginning of my secret project.
41.gif


^
all i can say is that we are truly spoiled with unfailing perfection with the majority of h&a/idealscope images on here and anything that is even a minutia different becomes less than spectacular. the stone you posted above looks awesome and will indeed exceed, performance wise, every other diamond you are likely to see on a daily basis.

i want to hear about this secret project!
20.gif
 

^

Rough_Rock
Joined
May 9, 2006
Messages
91
You're probably right, Belle. But when you arm a bunch of OCD crazies like us with more information than your average jewelry store manager, it's hard for us not to strive for perfection. I have yet to see Idealscope, Brilliancescope or HCA scores for the rocks I've seen in B&M's to know how those results would look IRL. I've only seen Tiffany or other chain B&M's so far. Want to make sure I'm well educated before ordering from online vendors so I order the right thing for inspection. f4fred's post was just so downright enthusiastic that my expectations may have been unreasonably high. But I was expecting every Infinity diamond to beat the best GOG or ACA diamonds from what he said. By beat, I guess I'm talking about Idealscope, but as GOG points out Idealscope has its limitations, and perhaps seeing these stones in person is the only way to do them justice.

My secret project is along the same lines as f4fred's, I believe. But I won't threadjack, I'll post my own when I've done more homework.
2.gif


Oh, and I should add, congratulations f4fred, I truly envy your Antwerp adventure, what a great experience to have attached to your lifelong commitment. So cool!

^
 

strmrdr

Super_Ideal_Rock
Joined
Nov 1, 2003
Messages
23,295
Date: 5/22/2006 8:38:50 PM
Author: ^
Thanks for the feedback on your experience. I looked around their site somewhat and am not as blown away by their selection as I was expecting. For instance:


.904 AGS0 F IF

http://www.infinitydiamonds.be/diamond.php?ID=100

http://www.elmyrservices.net/stonepreview.php?id=fb80ff014a0e245dc7cceeb6c0a51fba&cid=2

Click on Visagem Page 2


The H&A image is not great. The Idealscope image is not great either, in my amateur opinion. Do others agree? I know you said that perfect H&A doesn''t promise a good stone, and that''s true. But for you to ''categorically say that every stone that these guys produce exceeds every other stone'' is a pretty strong statement, and I''ve seen far better Idealscope images elsewhere. Maybe Paul showed you the best that he had, and it was your impression that all Infinity stones were of that caliber?


Not trying to threadcrxx, just trying to keep the dialog open. I''m still at the beginning of my secret project.
41.gif



^

elmyrservices did a crappy job of taking the picture more than there being anything wrong with the diamond.
 

Dancing Fire

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Apr 3, 2004
Messages
33,852
yep...if they don't line up the camera ,hearts will look
14.gif
 

^

Rough_Rock
Joined
May 9, 2006
Messages
91
Seriously? So I read all the material and learn how to closely scrutinize images of diamonds in an H&A viewer and an Idealscope image, etc, and now I have to contend with the fact that the camera might be off?

32.gif


OK, I''ll try to relax. How do we know from that picture that it''s the camera? Perhaps if I learned to judge that, too?

^
 

JulieN

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jul 25, 2005
Messages
13,375
in the arrows picture, it looks symmetrical. in the Idealscope picture, it doesn't look symmetrical. it's either exhibits symmetry, or it doesn't.

strm is really good at seeing the little things with the camera in pictures.

elmyr doesn't own the stone, so maybe they care less about taking good pictures than a vendor would (because I hate the IS pictures they take)

sometimes, I think when you've been here a little while, just enough to know quite a lot, you really do OCD on cut...nothing can be wonky, no partial leakage. but then you're here a little while longer and you're kinda, "eh, it's round, it has hearts and arrows, and top light return."
 

f4fred

Rough_Rock
Joined
Apr 3, 2006
Messages
16
The H&A thing is actually something I forgot to mention. I had been looking at loads of these things online and criticising this part of an arrow looking slightly different from that part. When you actually see the H&A in real life, the whole picture is dynamic as your head wobbles ever so slightly, so even a perfectly symmetrical H&A pattern can look off if your eye, or the camera sees the stone from anything but directly above. The same for the idealscope.

A second problem is that the diamond has to be perfectly centered in the viewer with the table perfectly parallel to the background else you can get the impression that there is lack of symmetry when in fact there is not.

As I am not an industry expert, my assertions about the Infinity line are only the result of my own research and personal perceptions. They are amazing!

As for my secret project... it involves a beautiful girl who I adore to pieces, a desire to buy a gorgeous ring that will make her super happy and far far far too much time on pricescope, visiting appraisers and cutters
26.gif
It is a bit like the ''DaVinci Ring'' - involving international travel across Europe and the US, muchos research on the black-art of diamonds, secret phone calls, anonymous appraiser meetings, and a marriage that no-one really quite knows about yet.
31.gif
 

^

Rough_Rock
Joined
May 9, 2006
Messages
91
f4fred, thanks for sharing your experience, I do tend to forget about "real world" observation factors, since we spend all day comparing stones in the vaccuum of HCA, IS, BS, etc. You''ve certainly seen a lot more diamonds than I have, and your compelling testimonial convinces me to give them a look when my search gets to that point.

Good luck with the "project!"

^
 

WinkHPD

Ideal_Rock
Trade
Joined
May 3, 2001
Messages
7,516
Date: 5/22/2006 8:11:13 PM
Author: f4fred
Thanks once more, not only to Wink and Paul, but also to everyone here on Pricescope who have provided excellent advice, lots of
34.gif
for my secret project, and a new found ability to generate worried looks on the faces of B&M jewlers!
LOL! Thirty-five years in the trade and I have finally excelled at teaching my clients to scare B&M jewelers...

Somehow I thought I was accomplishing MORE than that.
20.gif


Wink

P.S. Thank goodness I was drinking water not hot coffee when I read that. Still hurts to snort it all over the key board, but not nearly as much as hot coffee!
 

WinkHPD

Ideal_Rock
Trade
Joined
May 3, 2001
Messages
7,516
Date: 5/22/2006 8:38:50 PM
Author: ^
Thanks for the feedback on your experience. I looked around their site somewhat and am not as blown away by their selection as I was expecting. For instance:

.904 AGS0 F IF
http://www.infinitydiamonds.be/diamond.php?ID=100
http://www.elmyrservices.net/stonepreview.php?id=fb80ff014a0e245dc7cceeb6c0a51fba&cid=2
Click on Visagem Page 2

The H&A image is not great. The Idealscope image is not great either, in my amateur opinion. Do others agree? I know you said that perfect H&A doesn''t promise a good stone, and that''s true. But for you to ''categorically say that every stone that these guys produce exceeds every other stone'' is a pretty strong statement, and I''ve seen far better Idealscope images elsewhere. Maybe Paul showed you the best that he had, and it was your impression that all Infinity stones were of that caliber?

Not trying to threadcrxx, just trying to keep the dialog open. I''m still at the beginning of my secret project.
41.gif


^
^,

Welcome to our world.

Paul has Elmyr take the photos and do the measurements as that way he can not be accused of taking only the best shots or otherwise affecting the measurements. (Yes, you can move them around a little to get better shots from the same stone sometimes, especially with the idealscope as it is VERY easy to not have it perfectly perpendicular which messes things up.)

If they take a bad picture Paul lives with it. If it is obviously tilted or what ever he can ask that they re do it. I find his having an uninterested third party do this work to be a measure of his high ethical standards. They do a lot of work for many people so they are not nearly as careful at it as Paul would be if he were doing it himself. I can tell you that from my experience that the quality of Paul''s stones is incredibly consistent.

You are fortunate to be doing your search here, as there are many fine vendors to choose from and they are all competing dilligently for your hard earned dollars, so you will be paying a much lower price than you would otherwise find. I wish you well in your search.

Wink
 

WinkHPD

Ideal_Rock
Trade
Joined
May 3, 2001
Messages
7,516
Date: 5/22/2006 9:15:05 PM
Author: ^
But when you arm a bunch of OCD crazies like us with more information than your average jewelry store manager, it''s hard for us not to strive for perfection. I have yet to see Idealscope, Brilliancescope or HCA scores for the rocks I''ve seen in B&M''s to know how those results would look IRL.

Oh, and I should add, congratulations f4fred, I truly envy your Antwerp adventure, what a great experience to have attached to your lifelong commitment. So cool!

^
LOL! A serious Pricescoper knows more than most jewelry store OWNERS! There are tens of thousands of jewelers in this country alone, and I would be that the truly educated and up to date with modern technology number less than one thousand. I would like to believe that it is higher, but there are some on this board who would fare very well on any of the trade tests for knowledge about diamond cutting. (Of which there are not very many.) (Tests, not knowledgeable Pricescopers!)

Any one can open a jewelry store if he has the financial where withal, it does not require any special licensing. It takes a LOT of hard work to keep up with the tremendous advances being made in technology and in diamond cutting analysis today. Your reward for being one of those who does is the certainty that your purchase will be an incredible diamond to enhance the hand of the lady you love.

Wink

P.S. I left your last statement rather than sniping it, as this is the type of thing that one tells the grand kids, long after the technical knowledge is forgotten.
 

Modified Brilliant

Brilliant_Rock
Trade
Joined
Mar 24, 2005
Messages
1,529

f4fred

Rough_Rock
Joined
Apr 3, 2006
Messages
16
Heya Jeff, it looks like I have sold you a little short in my previous write-up, sorry. Jeff Averbook is my man in Boston who kindly handled all of my stones and put up with me bugging him for hours!

If you are looking for a trusty appraiser and would rather see an ''internet'' diamond before buying it, do make sure to give him a call. He basically made it possible for me to see lots of stones without having to put whacking great deposits or pre-payments down first - which would have halted my search here.

Hope to catch you soon Jeff.
 

Paul-Antwerp

Ideal_Rock
Trade
Joined
Sep 2, 2002
Messages
2,859
Hello Fred,

Thank you for the raving review. I was so embarassed by your outspoken enthousiasm here, that I did not dare to leave the building these last days. If all else fails in your good-looking professional career, you can always become a copywriter.

Thank you also for those of you who point to the quality of our pics. As you know, we outsource this, as this is not our specialty, and it frees up time to concentrate on what we are really good at. However, we often complain about the quality of some of our pics, and that this service could definitely improve, and to be able to point at a thread on PS where our consumers are complaining, definitely supports our case with Elmyr.

That being said, we are slowly preparing for the JCK-show in Vegas, where we will meet up with colleagues and especially our dealers. We will also have a dealers'' meeting in which we will discuss possible improvements to our products, our communication and our whole marketing package. Expect to see some other improvements soon.

Live long,
 

Modified Brilliant

Brilliant_Rock
Trade
Joined
Mar 24, 2005
Messages
1,529

Small

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Feb 2, 2006
Messages
958
36.gif
I can only imagine how beautiful your infinity diamond is as I''m a proud owner of one too
30.gif


I can attest that the stones Paul cuts are beautiful
30.gif
30.gif
My pictures on elmyr were very deceiving. I have an SI2 stone that has a feather on the edge. In the picture the feather looks big and black. When Wink received the diamond and forwarded me the pictures the feather is white as can be and made me very very happy to see
30.gif
I got an incredible diamond for a great price and worked with Wink who provided me service that far exceeded my expectations.

There are so many rave reviews for others on this site but from what I''ve seen Paul''s diamonds could infact hang with any of the diamonds that those vendors are selling. Your eyes are the true test. I have only the best regards for both Paul and Wink. They are highly highly recommended by me
36.gif
 

WinkHPD

Ideal_Rock
Trade
Joined
May 3, 2001
Messages
7,516
Thank you Small for your kind words. Paul is very dedicated to producing excellence and I consider myself to be very fortunate to be one of his vendors.

Wink
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
Be a part of the community Get 3 HCA Results
Top