Budget ring 1500$~ pls advice

[msop04]

Just looking through MyDiamondZone's eBay store, here are a few options that might work! One of the two halo settings below, paired with one of the diamonds below. I suggest contacting Ilya, the owner, to make sure the diamond you want will fit in the setting. He's super nice to work with, btw. I've had a few custom things made by him, and have talked to him a lot over the last few years. Always very helpful. And his prices are very reasonable!

The settings below will also work with modern cuts btw, let me see if I can find some good modern cut options...

I really love this halo, and it's a GREAT price!
http://www.ebay.ca/itm/VINTAGE-DIAM...927916?hash=item238814ec2c:g:fUkAAOSwZ4dZN2n2

...with this diamond.
http://www.ebay.ca/itm/0-67ct-VINTA...267445?hash=item2838b7e435:g:j-EAAOSwceNZUe4q

Boom. Done.

 

[msop04]

Here are two more settings... both halos, but would give a more substantial look. Either could be used to set the stone I linked above.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/ART-DECO-DI...3f4dddb&pid=100005&rk=6&rkt=6&sd=172764888218

http://www.ebay.com/itm/VINTAGE-DIA...LIGREE-HALO-/172764888218?hash=item283996fc9a

 

[SimoneDi]

I saw this one again today on LT, really pretty ring in my opinion, but I am not sure if you would like the style. A Bit overbudget, but maybe negotiable? https://loupetroop.com/listings/rin...iamond-and-calibre-sapphire-halo-ring-8-dot-5

 

[D maklen]

msop4 thank for your kind words and bringing light to this searching. But I think none of above wasnt what im looking for.

This one keep me thinking is it the one http://www.jewelsbygrace.com/tiffany-co-diamond-half-eternity-band

I know that jewelsbygrace is legit but it still keeps me thinking how can it be so "cheap" compare other similiar ones sold by ebay. Too good to be true?

This one is also nice one:

https://www.gabrielny.com/engagement-ring/ER912142R0W44JJ.CSD4

 

[msop04]

I saw this one again today on LT, really pretty ring in my opinion, but I am not sure if you would like the style. A Bit overbudget, but maybe negotiable? https://loupetroop.com/listings/rin...iamond-and-calibre-sapphire-halo-ring-8-dot-5

Oh wow... I really like that ring. Maybe the seller would take less??

 

[D maklen]

I saw this one again today on LT, really pretty ring in my opinion, but I am not sure if you would like the style. A Bit overbudget, but maybe negotiable? https://loupetroop.com/listings/rin...iamond-and-calibre-sapphire-halo-ring-8-dot-5

I think thats not her style but it looks nice. Theres no problem if price goes more than 1500$ if its the "one".

 

[msop04]

msop4 thank for your kind words and bringing light to this searching. But I think none of above wasnt what im looking for.

This one keep me thinking is it the one http://www.jewelsbygrace.com/tiffany-co-diamond-half-eternity-band

I know that jewelsbygrace is legit but it still keeps me thinking how can it be so "cheap" compare other similiar ones sold by ebay. Too good to be true?

This one is also nice one:

https://www.gabrielny.com/engagement-ring/ER912142R0W44JJ.CSD4

D, some people search for MONTHS before finding the "right" diamond and/or setting... so you are on the right track by coming to pricescope!

Regarding the Tiffany band... I thought your lady said she only likes halo style engagement rings? If so, then I would get her a halo. Personally, if I desired a halo, I would be disappointed in a band as my engagement ring... even a lovely one such as the Tiff & Co listed.

The Gabriel ring is okay... I'm not in love. I'm not really in like. You can get her a more substantial diamond than that.

 

[Niel]

Honestly I say buy the Tiffany's. You're not going to make a new one with any negligible size difference. It's got cache being Tiffany, it's platinum, and it's got a vintage appeal . I don't think you'll do much better than that if you can swing the price

 

[msop04]

Looking for a halo setting because I know that is what she only wants.

...I'm really confused as to why the OP keeps going back to a band. Did I miss something?

OP, do you think she'd be okay with just the Tiff band?

 

[Niel]

D, some people search for MONTHS before finding the "right" diamond and/or setting... so you are on the right track by coming to pricescope!

Regarding the Tiffany band... I thought your lady said she only likes halo style engagement rings? If so, then I would get her a halo. Personally, if I desired a halo, I would be disappointed in a band as my engagement ring... even a lovely one such as the Tiff & Co listed.

The Gabriel ring is okay... I'm not in love. I'm not really in like. You can get her a more substantial diamond than that.

I suspect he linked the wrong link.hes considering a Tiffany Halo at Jbg

 

[msop04]

I suspect he linked the wrong link.hes considering a Tiffany Halo at Jbg

Ahhh... that makes more sense!

Yes, the circlet ring is cute and a really nice find at that price.

 

[MollyMalone]

I don't remember seeing this on the eBayUK web site when I was doing a search for you this past weekend.

• It's a platinum halo ring, which looks to be well made and in excellent condition; has pavé down past the shoulders of the shank; asking price is (using today's exchange rate) $1605 USD or 1408 Euros.
• The center stone has been graded by GIA as D in color, VS1 in clarity; vendor is in the UK; and does have 14-day return-refund policy (you have to scroll down through the listing to see that).
• May not need to be resized since it's about a UK size J-1/2.

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/GIA-CERTI...iamond-Engagement-Ring-RRP-3750-/322567146616

At .35 ct, the center stone is larger than .25 ct one in the Tiffany circlet ring. But the Tiffany ring has a higher total carat weight. Since you keep going back to the Tiffany ring, that may be your cue that it really is The One

 

[Niel]

I don't remember seeing this on the eBayUK web site when I was doing a search for you this past weekend.

• It's a platinum halo ring, which looks to be well made and in excellent condition; has pavé down past the shoulders of the shank; asking price is (using today's exchange rate) $1605 USD or 1408 Euros.
• The center stone has been graded by GIA as D in color, VS1 in clarity; vendor is in the UK; and does have 14-day return-refund policy (you have to scroll down through the listing to see that).
• May not need to be resized since it's about a UK size J-1/2.

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/GIA-CERTI...iamond-Engagement-Ring-RRP-3750-/322567146616

At .35 ct, the center stone is larger than .25 ct one in the Tiffany circlet ring. But the Tiffany ring has a higher total carat weight. Since you keep going back to the Tiffany ring, that may be your cue that it really is The One

I remember seeing this one and can't remember why I didn't share it. I think I was hoping for a larger stone. However, since we're considering the Tiffany one, I suppose it isn't too small. The fact it doesn't have vat, probably has cheaper shipping, and is already her size, in my opinion, bumps it up above the Tiffany. But, if you think the Tiffany is the one, I understand that too

 

[Niel]

Of the two I think the cushion would be more flattering on the hand

 

[SimoneDi]

What about this one? https://loupetroop.com/listings/rings/dot-74-oec-in-halo
Says USA only, but maybe it is worth asking if you cover all shipping costs.

 

[Niel]

What about this one? https://loupetroop.com/listings/rings/dot-74-oec-in-halo
Says USA only, but maybe it is worth asking if you cover all shipping costs.

My only concern about that is the setting. The company that makes that setting makes fun setting but they are not really made to last a lifetime

 

[MollyMalone]

What about this one? https://loupetroop.com/listings/rings/dot-74-oec-in-halo
Says USA only, but maybe it is worth asking if you cover all shipping costs.

My only concern about that is the setting. The company that makes that setting makes fun setting but they are not really made to last a lifetime

I'm wondering about the bona fides of that listing. Grace has the loose stone listed on her web site:
http://www.jewelsbygrace.com/74ct-old-european-cut-diamond-gia-k-i1

 

[SimoneDi]

My only concern about that is the setting. The company that makes that setting makes fun setting but they are not really made to last a lifetime

Oh good to know..I had no idea. Hm.. what about something like this stone (at a better price) https://loupetroop.com/listings/loose-stones/dot-84-j-vs-2-round-diamond-stone-only in a cheaper halo?

 

[Marge_C]

Just chiming in as I'm looking for something along similar lines. There's a very nice 18k solitaire setting with platinum prongs at BlueNile which leaves quite a bit left over for a centre stone. They will upgrade the stone at a later date or you ship it back in and get a halo setting for more finger coverage. Whitefish also has a fantastic selection of extremely well cut diamonds and a lifetime upgrade program.

GIA and AGS are the most respected diamond grading labs. AGS has detailed cut information on their certificates and most super ideal and specialty cut diamonds will have an AGS certificate. Whiteflash carries a large number of AGS certified stones so you can compare GIA and AGS reports.

https://www.bluenile.com/au/diamond-details/LD08866472

https://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/round-cut-loose-diamond-3811448.htm
http://www.agslab.com/pdf_sync_reports/104089609037-PGRH.PDF

When looking for a diamond it's a good start to use the filters and set it to Ideal cut, VS2 and up, and I colour and up.

Some would rather get a bigger stone by choosing an SI, but I'm nearsighted so it's VS etc. Some women are also colour sensitive and there's some debate about getting a larger diamond with a bit more warmth like a J stone, a smaller (for the same $) near colourless such as G, H & I, or an even smaller colourless D, E or F. D colour has the least amount of colour and Z is the cutoff point before you dip into fancy colour stones. There are traditionalists who will only recommend a G/VS and above with no fluorescence for an engagement stone. It's a good idea to find out your partner's preference.

Ring shanks should be 2mm or thicker so they wear well and I personally prefer a platinum basket/head. Be aware that pave stones often go missing and any smaller prong set stones will need to be checked often to make sure they're not loose.

Some people don't want fluorescence in a stone. If you choose a stone with fluorescence it will glow under the blacklights at clubs and parties.

Check out the sections here on PriceScope on cut quality. A way to start to hone in on a pretty stone is to search up the diamond certificates online. Table should be about 57% or less and depth should be less than 62%. The Holloway Cut Advisor can help.

Antique cut diamonds are in their own category and you'd need a few photos to see if you like the cut. They're very unique.

With inclusions I personally stay away from chips, feathers, internal or external graining, and etch channels (lazer treated) all together.

A few other highly respected vendors are Brian Gavin, Goodoldgold, and of course James Allen. Lang Antiques has a large selection of antique rings which are fabulous and many of them are GIA certified.

Take your time. It's supposed to be fun

https://www.pricescope.com/tools/hca (Holloway Cut Advisor)

https://www.bluenile.com/au/build-your-own-ring/settings?track=NavEngSolitaire (18k solitaire setting)

https://www.whiteflash.com/engageme...fany-style-solitaire-engagement-ring-1078.htm

https://www.whiteflash.com

https://www.langantiques.com

https://www.goodoldgold.com

http://www.briangavindiamonds.com

 

[Snowdrop13]

The Tiffany Circlet ring is a great price, comes with a condition report from a respected appraiser and has the original box and paperwork with it. I'd far rather buy from Grace than eBay!

It also is more substantial in terms of carat weight and dimensions than the GabrielNY ring you posted.

 

[SimoneDi]

After looking again at the T&Co. ring and seeing the video, I actually also think that it is probably the best ring you can find in your budget, plus it is Tiffany's! I think that most people can appreciate the brand even if they are not necessarily after it. The ring comes with all its boxes + paperwork and appraisal and it is sold by a super reputable seller, doesn't get better than that. I also suspect that the ring won't be around for much longer, so it is probably good to act fast if that is the one.

 

[ccuheartnurse]

Came across this site that has reasonable stones. If you sign up for their newsletter, you get $100 off. I like this stone, & I would ask for a video as I've found them to be very accommodating.
https://www.yadavjewelry.com/products/round-diamond-i-si1-yd751196

Ask them if they can source an inexpensive halo.

I like this one from Stuller.com. Gold weight isn't heavy & there aren't that many stones. Might be worth looking at.
https://www.stuller.com/products/bu...tionSource=CategoryBrowse3C#/mounting-options

And this one is from My Diamond Zone but in Platinum which would be more secure than gold. I'd give this one a chance, it's very pretty & I think would look great.

http://www.ebay.ca/itm/G-VS-DIAMOND...NG-ART-DECO-/152612143415?hash=item2388648137
$515 US.

Enjoying the options you've been shown on this thread. So many creative minds.

Judy

 

[D maklen]

I want to thank you all again for this great options you have provided! It really mean much to me because im quite bad for picking up good ones.

Earlier, yes I posted wrong link about Tiffanys, sorry for that but I guess you already found the right one. ( http://www.jewelsbygrace.com/signed-pieces/tiffany-co-circlet-ring )

This MollyMalones posted halo ring got my attention http://www.ebay.com/itm/GIA-CERTIFI...gement-Ring-RRP-3750-/322567146616?rmvSB=true
its from UK so I dont have to pay taxes and maybe it even fits without re-sizing!
Its from Ebay and seller with 171 positive feedback but still dont feel so reliable with it. Maybe im too paranoid to buy second hand from ebay

How much you think that tiffany ring costs brand new? How much someone has paid when it have been new, any guesses?

Any idea how old that ring is? Do you think its going to be sustainable for coming future years?

And here is posted documentation. ( https://jewelsbygrace.smugmug.com/S...and-Bands/Tiffany-Co-Circlet-Ring/i-vLsxG3b/A) Is that the GIA report? It doesnt tell center stone details, just that its 0.25ct. I try to find that report in GIA's search but nothing found with ID number LC435 which shown on the documentation.

Sorry for my silly questions and poor english as its not my native languange

Im like 1 millimeter or (inch as u say) away from buying that Tiffanys!

If you have to make choice between Tiffanys and that MollyMalones posted link which one would you choose?

 

[Niel]

At today's prices that tiffany ring would sell between 3000 and 5500 usd based on their current selection

This was probably made in the 90s or 00s

Platinum rings last 100 years plus when they are taken care of. It won't call apart on you

 

[SimoneDi]

What Neil said..just the Tiffany name carries a value, the same cannot be said for the other ring. The other ring is nothing special to me .. just a typical halo like 1027484 other models these days. My original engagement ring was platinum and it dated back to 1920s, after polishing it always looked brand new. Tiffany Circlet is my choice, it will look pretty sizable, too. Not too long ago I actually saw someone with the "triple" circlet version, which they still carry today, as an e-ring and it looked lovely.

 

[Diamond*Dana]

I agree with the Tiffany ring. That's a great price on a beautiful ring. You really can't go wrong there.

 

[rockysalamander]

I think you have two good options, but they seem to fit very different tastes. I may have missed this, but can you describe your girl? {I'm trying to channel Gypsy here} How does she dress? Does she follow fashion or make her own style? What is her profession? Does she have a closet of shoes/purses? Does she like vintage or antique things or clothing? Does she love Ikea style or French provincial? Is she someone that wants to get others approval or march to her own drummer?

 

[D maklen]

I think you have two good options, but they seem to fit very different tastes. I may have missed this, but can you describe your girl? {I'm trying to channel Gypsy here} How does she dress? Does she follow fashion or make her own style? What is her profession? Does she have a closet of shoes/purses? Does she like vintage or antique things or clothing? Does she love Ikea style or French provincial? Is she someone that wants to get others approval or march to her own drummer?

She is 27 years old. She got long straight blond hair. Loves shoes and purses.

She loves design furniture. Works in management multinational company.

Business wear to casual relax clothing. Maybe more modern things than antique.

She doesnt care others approval. Hope this help!

 

[EllieTO]

I've been following this thread closely and am curious to see what you'll pick in the end.

I agree with rockysalamander that between those two, your choice should be based on what style she would prefer, and how she feels about a vintage style and pre-owned ring. Some ladies really would not like the idea of a pre-owned ring. No one can answer that question for you about your girlfriend. Out of those two I personally would pick the ebay one for myself rather than the Tiffany because I like the style better and the Tiffany name is not important to me, but I may be in the minority.

I'm just wondering why you've totally ruled out James Allen? I think you can get a beautiful brand new ring in your budget that will be very similar to the ebay one, but you'll have peace of mind and a reliable return policy, just in case. It seems like you don't really want the hassle of dealing with private sellers, and being in Europe makes it a bit harder too.
I think either of these settings posted previously would leave enough room for a nice diamond.
https://www.jamesallen.com/engageme...-halo-engagement-ring-round-center-item-18301
https://www.jamesallen.com/engageme...ellis-halo-diamond-engagement-ring-item-53050
I wouldn't go with the one JA recommended for you, with the pave band, because it doesn't leave enough budget for the diamond.
For the diamond, you'd have about $680 to spend. I'm not an expert so I'd rather not post a suggestion, but if this is the route you decide to take, the members here will pick the absolute best choice to maximize value for your budget. From what I see, you can afford a bigger center stone than the 0.35 ct in the ebay ring.

I hope I didn't confuse you further but I really think JA is still an option to consider, and may cause less stress for you.

 

[MollyMalone]

* * * How much you think that tiffany ring costs brand new? How much someone has paid when it have been new, any guesses?
Any idea how old that ring is? Do you think its going to be sustainable for coming future years?

And here is posted documentation. ( https://jewelsbygrace.smugmug.com/S...and-Bands/Tiffany-Co-Circlet-Ring/i-vLsxG3b/A) Is that the GIA report? It doesnt tell center stone details, just that its 0.25ct. I try to find that report in GIA's search but nothing found with ID number LC435 which shown on the documentation.

Sorry for my silly questions and poor english as its not my native languange

Im like 1 millimeter or (inch as u say) away from buying that Tiffanys!
If you have to make choice between Tiffanys and that MollyMalones posted link which one would you choose?

I did searches on both Google and Bing, using various time spans. It looks to me as if Tiffany first introduced the Circlet Collection in 2007: November 2007 is the earliest date I'm seeing any references to Circlet pieces. So I doubt the Circlet ring that you're considering is more than 10 years. In his Qualitative Pre-Sale Report, independent appraiser David Atlas (who posts here as Old Miner) says the markings inside the ring are -- as we can see in the photos -- clear (not worn away in any respect) & that the mounting is in very good condition.

You're right that LC 435 is not a GIA report number (it has too few numbers; think LC 435 is a number Mr. Atlas assigns for his own record-keeping purposes.) FYI you would not have received a GIA report had you purchased this ring new: Tiffany's smaller diamonds don't come with GIA reports; they are graded only by Tiffany "in house."

Of the two, I now think the Tiffany Circlet ring would definitely be your better choice since you've described your wife-to-be as having more modern tastes than antique. The eBay UK ring I linked has millegrain (the teeny beading around the edges) & that's a more "vintage" detail. The Circlet ring's inner and outer bezels, however, don't have any millegraining; the bezels' and the shank edges are entirely smooth. That's "fresher", has a more contemporary look to my eye.

And please, there is noooo need for you to apologize for your English -- it is very good!!