Back for More PS Help

[robtali]

Here we go again, I''m back in the market. This forum was such a help to me in Dec 05 when I bought a diamond that I couldn''t pass on the opportunity for some more helpful feedback!
I am looking at two possibilities from WF, listed below. The second is not in-house. They are bringing it in and will send IS, Sarin, Cert, etc... in a day or two. Any thoughts?

ES 1.023 I SI1 $4650 ($4511ps) AGS-8491908
http://www.whiteflash.com/round_ideal_cut/Round-Ideal-Cut-cut-diamond-358388.htm
White inclusion at 6" - eye-clean at 20"

*or*

Round 1.21 J VS2 GIA M-STK
Depth=62.5%
Crown=57%
Crown=14.5%
Pavillion=43.5%
6.75x6.79x4.23 $4313/$4260

 

[QD Rocks]

Hi,

why dont you look at both stones and make your own mind up. Or

What is your total budget as a H SI1 slightly lighter but cut better might be a better option.

Kind Regards

Paul

 

[diamondseeker2006]

The I SI1 looks very nice, but the other stone is too deep. It will often make the diameter of the stone smaller than it should be when they are too deep. Try to stick with depths between 60 and 62. I would not consider the second stone. The last time I looked, it seemed like they had a couple of other I SI1's around a carat. You might want to check.

 

[Lorelei]

First diamond looks fine, the second is a little deeper than some of us prefer, but see what WF advise when they see it.