- Joined
- Feb 17, 2018
- Messages
- 32
Hello again PS!
My gosh has it been a journey. To feel as clueless as I did last week to now becoming overly OCD about this whole process.
First I got to say thank you to all the kind people that replied to me. It was a huge help hearing all your advice and I tried as best I could to implement them. I wish we were a bit more competent at picking out our engagement ring, but I still feel we need help.
I spent some time coming through what is out there and narrowed down some choices
I was hoping you could tell me where I maybe wrong in having these as the final 3, and which could be eliminated. They are all within TIC range. Ranging from hca score 0.6 - 1.7
For context, the diamond will be set in a yellow gold 6 prong so...
First the most questionable a 1.23C, J VS2
With a questionable ‘faint greenish yellow’ and IGI report :/
Hca score 0.6
$5k
Second
1.01 H SI2 (eye clean?) slightly large CA @ 36*
HCA score 1.7
$4.8k
Lastly the visual favorite but more pricey
1.01C. J VVS2 HCA score 1.3
$5.5k
35.5ca 40.6pa 56%table 62.2% depth
Since the setting is yellow gold the larger carat 1.23 J faint greenish yellow is tempting.
However I am hoping you could let us know if it’s worth the $ to just go with the visually pleasing J VVS2
I hope I have made this as easy enough, to not waste any more of your time.
Appreciate all you’re guidance in this !!
My gosh has it been a journey. To feel as clueless as I did last week to now becoming overly OCD about this whole process.
First I got to say thank you to all the kind people that replied to me. It was a huge help hearing all your advice and I tried as best I could to implement them. I wish we were a bit more competent at picking out our engagement ring, but I still feel we need help.
I spent some time coming through what is out there and narrowed down some choices
I was hoping you could tell me where I maybe wrong in having these as the final 3, and which could be eliminated. They are all within TIC range. Ranging from hca score 0.6 - 1.7
For context, the diamond will be set in a yellow gold 6 prong so...
First the most questionable a 1.23C, J VS2
With a questionable ‘faint greenish yellow’ and IGI report :/
Hca score 0.6
$5k
Second
1.01 H SI2 (eye clean?) slightly large CA @ 36*
HCA score 1.7
$4.8k
Lastly the visual favorite but more pricey
1.01C. J VVS2 HCA score 1.3
$5.5k
35.5ca 40.6pa 56%table 62.2% depth
Since the setting is yellow gold the larger carat 1.23 J faint greenish yellow is tempting.
However I am hoping you could let us know if it’s worth the $ to just go with the visually pleasing J VVS2
I hope I have made this as easy enough, to not waste any more of your time.
Appreciate all you’re guidance in this !!
finalists.
300x240.png)