Asscher....the saga continues

[tlcdasha]

O.K. guys, I nixed the last pick, but found another.
Feel free to blast away.
I did have a copy of the GIA cert. forwarded to me (dated December 23, 2002), but I am having trouble uploading it.
The website has a 30-day $-back gurantee. I thought this price was a little tooo good to be true, considering the fact that I have only seen 150 pt H-VS2 for this price range, and this is one whole color grade higher.


Certificate
GIA
Cut
Asscher
Carat
1.42
Color
G
Clarity
VS2
Regular Price
$ 6798
Wire Transfer Price
$ 6600
Measurements
6.49X6.24X4.11 mm
Depth Percentage
65.9 %
Table Percentage
66 %
Girdle
MED-STK
Culet
N
Polish
Good
Symmetry
Good
Fluorescence
N
Special Notes
Beautiful D

 

[niceice]

The numbers look good as far as we can tell from a GIA Graded stone without a Sarin / OGI report, but what does "beautiful D" mean? The stone is a G color...

 

[tlcdasha]

Sorry, but the rest was cut off but the sentence reads "Beautiful Diamond!"

I was pretty satisfied the specs/price and ready to buy, and then in the last hour I cam acrss another:

GIA:Square-emerald

6.33x6.22x4.52

H-VS2, 1.52carats

72.7%depth

58% table

NO culet/fluor.

Polish, Symm VG

I do fancy a larger stone but I am concerned with quality as well. Which would you choose?