shape
carat
color
clarity

Another noob looking for advice

  • Thread starter Thread starter KP
  • Start date Start date

KP

Rough_Rock
Joined
Jun 2, 2010
Messages
7
Hi folks, just joined on after trolling for a few weeks. Looking for a stone for an engagement ring and have a few I am considering from two sites.

Union Diamond sent me information on this one
http://www.uniondiamond.com/diamonds/diamonds.php?mod=search&search_type_id=2&action_type_id=2&item_id=AB647131
AB647131
It is a 1.58 carat, D color SI1 (eye-clean face up with only two small inclusions seen under the loop according to the email. My biggest concern with all of these diamonds is cute and although it is a Select Ideal cut, I went ahead and put the dimensions into the HCA and it came to a TIC 1.1.

To me it seems like the perfect diamond to suite my purpose, I am getting a quoted price $1100 down from msrp for going through pricescope and wire transfer.


Two other stones I found were beautiful were available through WhiteFlash.
One is a ACA stone which is TIC 1.4
http://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/round-cut-loose-diamond-2309001.htm
It is a 1.58, F, SI1. My understand is the hearts and arrows are neat, but don''t necessarily make for a better looking stone.

Another is an E stone which is also TIC 1.4
http://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/round-cut-loose-diamond-2329034.htm
It is a 1.51, D, SI1.

The discount for both of these is not as great as with union diamond and would cost ~$800-1000 more than the first diamond. My question is does the Union Diamond sound like a better deal? Is H&A really worth it if I only care about the look? Also, I really want to get a halo setting with platinum (although trying to decide on which alloy mix) so I want to be able to stay within a budget of $15000 total. The WF diamonds would have me stretching, but I am willing to pay a little more for quality (just doesn''t seem as if they are much better than the Union Diamond one).

The kicker is that I have a friend who can go visually see the stones at White Flash, but have no one who can do that for me with Union Diamond. Sorry for the crazy long post , but anyone have any thoughts? Thanks.

Ketan
5.gif
 
You are lurking not trolling. :P 2 totally different meaning.

UD stone looks promising, ask for an idealscope image.
 
I hope to speak with UD soon. I spoke with the individuals at WF but am not sure I can justify the price. It also seems as if the inclusions may be less on the stone from UD. Does the heart and arrow really make a big difference? Also, will inclusions stick out more in D stone vs F stone? Appreciate the info.

In regards to selecting a band, I have read many theories on what alloys are better than other for platinum... but does any of it really make a difference? I was thinking plat/ruthenium, but everyone charges a slight premium for it. Oh well.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top