Advise on 2 diamond choices

[diamonddumb]

Can some of the experts help me compare the 2 diamonds below? Which one is the better choice?

Choice # 1:
Carat - 1.5
Shape Round
Measurements - 7.3*7.38*4.53
Color - F
Clarity - SI1
Depth - 61.7%
Table - 60%
Girdle - Medium - Thick (Faceted)
Culet - Very small
Polish - Good
Symmetry - Good
Flourescence - None
Grading Lab - GIA
Cost - $11,300

Choice # 2:
Carat - 1.54
Shape Round
Measurements - 7.55*7.64*4.44
Color - G
Clarity - VS2
Depth - 58.5%
Table - 58%
Girdle - Thin - Thick (Faceted)
Culet - Very small
Polish - Good
Symmetry - Good
Flourescence - None
Grading Lab - GIA
Cost - $10,500

Thanks in advance for any help.

 

[pricescope]

based on these numbers I like #2.