Advice on two stones based on GIA reports

[Harrybob]

Hi, I'm after some help in deciding out of two stones which is the better stone.

I've attached the two GIA reports so if anyone can offer some advice as to which of the two would be the better stone on paper, it would be much appreciated.

 

[yoyosaidfeia]

Personally... Diamond_4, F/VVS1.
E/D/F are all colorless. Better clarity would be my preference.
Inclusions should not be visible with naked eye on VVS1/2.

From personal experience, my diamond is vvs2, I had to look very hard under a microscope to see the tiny feather in the corner.

Good luck

 

[Harrybob]

Thanks for the advice yoysaidfeia, that was the diamond I was leaning towards.

Does anyone else have any opinions of the the choice of the two stones?

 

[madelise]

You can't tell if a fancy cut diamond is good or not based on GIA reports alone. You need an ASET.

 

[madelise]

What are you searching for and what is your budget? Don't waste your money on VVS grading. VS is perfectly fine already. VVS is unnecessary and honestly a waste of $ since VS is usually eye clean.

 

[JulieN]

70+ depth is very common in princesses. that is not a red flag.

OP, any pictures, or are you buying in person? Have you considered going down in clarity?

 

[madelise]

70+ depth is very common in princesses. that is not a red flag.

OP, any pictures, or are you buying in person? Have you considered going down in clarity?

I just searched. I'm not a princess-gal, so this I just learned I was just coming back to retract that statement!

 

[BhavinJ]

I liked E VS1

Pls post the images once you have them.

 

[DiamondBrokersofFlorida]

I would ask for pictures. You might find one shape more pleasing than the other.

 

[Harrybob]

Ok thanks for everyones advice and opinions.

I have found another diamond that I am interested in as well although it seems to be of a higher spec but keep in mind all of these diamonds are of similar pricing.

Again I have attached the report and an image of the diamond, I could not get one that was magnified.