Advice on two diamonds

[apollocreed]

All,

Just wanted to get your thoughts on these two in terms of cut. Would appreciate your views as I'm still new to evaluating idealscope/ASET images. Two different price points, so would like your thoughts independent of one another. Thank you!

2.01ct/I/VS2
56 table
34 crown angle
40.8 pavillion
61.6 depth








1.81ct/H/VS2
57 table
35 crown angle
40.6 pavillion
61.8 depth

 

[apollocreed]

Thanks for the response JRR - very helpful and I can now see what you're pointing out as well.

Don't think they were advertised as such, but both are GIA 3EX and were promising on paper based off of the HCA. 1st one is ~19k, 2nd is ~15.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I'd definitely go for number 1 since it is over 2 cts. if greater size is desired and the person isn't color sensitive.

 

[apollocreed]

Hi all, just wanted your thoughts on the cut of one more diamond:

It's a 2.09 ct/VS1/I. Comes in cheaper than the 2.01 I posted above.