Advice between 4 diamonds

[dummy68]

Sorry for the second thread, but I'm changing my search based on what my gf's sister recommended. Therefore, I need advice on the following 4 diamonds. Which diamond do you feel is the best out of the 4? Which has the best Ideal Scope? I'm not sure what a good one is for a Princess cut.

Also, feel free to recommend another stone.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated!


Diamond 1
-AGS, 1.104ct, H, SI1, A Cut Above Princess, Depth: 74.3, Tbl: 70.8, Crown Angle: 41.4 Pavilion Angle: 40.2, Measurements: 5.66x5.61x4.2, Polish: Ideal, Symmetry: Ideal, Light Performance: 0

Diamond 2
-AGS, 1.012ct, H, VS2, A Cut Above Princess, Depth: 75.1, Tbl: 68.4, Crown Angle: 43.1 Pavilion Angle:
39.8, Measurements: 5.40x5.38x4.04, Polish: Ideal, Symmetry: Ideal, Light Performance: 0

Diamond 3
-AGS, 1.202ct, i, VS2, A Cut Above Princess, Depth: 75.3, Tbl: 71.4, Crown Angle: 43.5 Pavilion Angle:
40.3, Measurements: 5.72x5.70x4.29, Polish: Ideal, Symmetry: Ideal, Light Performance: 0

Diamond 4
-AGS, 1.027ct, i, VS1, A Cut Above Princess, Depth: 75.3, Tbl: 69.4, Crown Angle: 41.8 Pavilion Angle:
40.1, Measurements: 5.45x5.39x4.06, Polish: Ideal, Symmetry: Ideal, Light Performance: 0

 

[Shay37]

I like the IS on #4 for the bits of black that indicate good contrast or hotspots. I could not see an image or IS of #2. Having said that, I will say that if it has ACA on it (these all do) it''s going to be a more beautiful well cut princess than 99.5% of them out there. Flip a coin or pick the size you want. They are fairly marked price wise, and the rest will just be splitting hairs.

shay