J9Tiffany
Rough_Rock
- Joined
- Jan 15, 2019
- Messages
- 20
So I am in a dilemma and truthfully, the matter is pretty much closed but my obsessional thoughts are making me wonder if this diamond will be “perfect enough.” My fiance bought me a GORGEOUS 1.3ct RB classic 6 prong Tiffany Engagement Ring. Below are the stats and this diamond had tons of fire which I loved and Was noticed by everyone. The problem is that when it was shipped out for sizing through Tiffany’s, it was lost. I’m devastated and although the company has been attentive and took full responsibility for the situation, nothing will bring back my ring. Everyone I spoke to thought that the company should go above and beyond but they definitely went with lateral replacements which I guess I understand. They offered 2 replacement rings and their stats are also uploaded in PDF form. Fast forward to today...I chose the last one (or 2nd attached PDF) because although I originally had an SI1, it was perfectly eye clean with the only crystal inclusion under a prong. The SI1 diamond they showed me (first PDF attachment) had a cloud, feather and crystal, 2 of which were under the table facet. I had to request to have a second option to view, hence the 3rd diamond which I ultimately chose because it was higher clarity, VS1. However, I am obsessing over the fact that the table is 59% and worried that even though all other angles seem on point and it looked pretty that once I get it back from sizing (tomorrow or Thursday) and I see it in familiar daytime lighting at home, I’ll notice that it doesn’t have as much fire as my original ring which had a 56% table. I have a decent amount of diamond knowledge and know that you can’t just look at the numbers but this situation has been so upsetting that I am overanalyzing the numbers. Tiffany’s doesn’t offer an ASET scope image and I didn’t have my own personal scope to bring so I don’t have those. My original ring scored a 1.5 HCA score. The second diamond scored a 2.2 and the 3rd diamond which I chose scored a 1.5. Any expert advice out there or thoughts to ease my mind would help so much. Thanks guys! sad