56 table, 34.5 CA 40.9 pavillion

[Gemly]

Hey friends!
I am nearing the end of my search to replace my engagement ring. We’ve narrowed it down to two choices. The first I’ve already discussed here in a separate thread, and now we have one other option being shipped, which should arrive in the next few days. This is .65ct bigger-which of course I love...but I’m alittle unsure about the 40.9 pavillion angle paired with a 34.5 crown. What do you guys think of this combo? How will it compare with the other stone we are debating between in fire, brilliance and performance? Specs as follows:


(the new option being shipped .65 ct. bigger)

table: 56%
Ca: 34.5 - 15%
pa: 40.9 - 43%
Girdle: medium
depth: 61.8
LGF: 76
(Will take ASET after receiving)


For comparison the other stone for consideration (smaller by .65ct. )


Table: 57.5
Crown: 15%- 34.7
Pavilion: 43% - 40.7
Girdle- Medium
LGF: 80
Depth: 61.2
(Good ASET)

Thank you, thank you, thank you!!! ... for being an invaluable help in this process!!!! ❤

 

[LittleKite]

40.9 pavillion is not a problem at all. The two diamonds will have quite different arrow patterns given the difference in LGF. I personally will choose the new one since I like smaller table and bolder arrows.

 

[Gemly]

40.9 pavillion is not a problem at all. The two diamonds will have quite different arrow patterns given the difference in LGF. I personally will choose the new one since I like smaller table and bolder arrows.

Thanks Littlekite!
Can’t wait for it to arrive so I can check them both our head to head in person. I’m interested to see how their personalities differ. Glad to hear 40.9 paired with 34.5 isn’t an issue!