5 stone ring...idj or whiteflash

[whiteolive]

pricescope quality stones, S1 clarity, 14kt from idj is $1350 for o.75ctw. Whiteflash has aca melee stones for $1500 but I think these are higher clarity stones. Which one to choose??

 

[whiteolive]

Sorry whiteflash is $1550 with vs, aca melee stones. And it is for the shared prong 5 stone ring

 

[tyty333]

If the slight increase is in your budget then I would definitely go with Whiteflash. I think it is a couple
hundred you wont regret spending. IDJ is nice to but since the price is fairly close I would go with
WF.

 

[PintoBean]

I like both vendors you are picking from. At this point I think I'd go with the one you feel more comfortable with regarding service and return and exchange policies.

 

[marcy]

I would go with Whiteflash. I have several WF melee bands and absolutely love them. I know many people on here are very happy with IDJ diamonds so I think you'd be happy with their ring as well but for about $150 difference I'd rather have the VS diamonds. What color are the IDJ diamonds?

 

[whiteolive]

The color is the same range from both venders

 

[marcy]

Whiteolive, I think you'd be happy with either vendor but for $150 difference I would go for the higher clarity and ACA melee.

 

[ac117]

I absolutely love IDJ and have gotten many pieces from them-beautiful quality at unbeatable prices. However, for the $150 difference, I'd be very tempted to go with WF for their ACA melee!

 

[alene]

I'd go with ACA considering the minimal price difference.

 

[AprilBaby]

You would not be sorry if you went with the ACA. Gorgeous stones!