2 similar stone - brand vs non brand, choose which one?

[astar11]

Just some random question, in between these 2 stones, which one will you choose and why?

A. Branded Stone - HA
Carat: 1.9
Color: E / VS 1
Fluor: None
Table: 54.8
Depth: 62
Crown Angle: 34.4
Pav angle: 40.8
Star: 53
Lower Girdle %: 78
Price: A is $4000 more expensive than B

B. Non Branded Stone
Carat: 1.9
Color: E / VS 1
Fluor: None
Table: 55
Depth: 61.3
Crown Angle: 34.1
Pav angle: 40.7
Star: 55
Lower girdle %: 79


Just based on numbers alone without looking at the ideal scope, which one will you choose?

 

[JulieN]

Well they are incredibly similar, most likely it would be difficult to tell them apart.

 

[astar11]

Thanks jullie. Any other answer??

 

[treasurehunter]

Stone B is 4000 dollars cheaper ???
I prefer stone B !!!

 

[smilligan]

Haha. What brand is it? Must be HOF or one of the high end jewelers. That's just crazy.

 

[astar11]

It is ACA. My point is will you still get ACA just because it is ACA or will you get the non brand one?

 

[Sidius]

The numbers seem pretty identical but I'd want to see images of both before deciding whether it's worth the extra $$$. $4k is a lot though.

 

[SB621]

I would go with whichever one is more visual appealing. You don't wear the paper saying the brand on your finger. However if they both are the same as far as visual appeal you bet I would go for the cheaper one.