A Guide to the Best Jewelry Stores in Seattle

Seattle is home to mountains, oceans, rainforests, deserts, cities, farms, islands, and even a volcano. But what about diamonds? 

As opposed to most of the cities we have written about, Seattle does not have a fashion or shopping district, certainly not one as prominent as New York’s Diamond District.

You may spend some serious time in the car getting around to visit several jewelers in the city. While we love the experience of Pike Place Market, it’s not exactly teeming with fine jewelers.

Don’t want to pass up on the chance for incredible seafood, a relaxed atmosphere, and all that beautiful greenery? 

Online retailers have also established roots in Seattle and the Seattle area, offering designer settings, high-quality diamonds and lab-grown diamonds of all classes and categories due to advancing technology. The city definitely has some tricks up its sleeves, discover what Seattle’s best jewelry stores have to offer below.

Don’t want to settle in Seattle?  We recommend Whiteflash, Blue Nile, and James Allen, vetted vendors offering quality diamonds, complete with high-quality images and videos and equipped with reputable diamond certificates - all accessible online from your own home.

1. Blue Nile – Best for Selection and Competitive Pricing

Blue Nile

Location: 177 Bellevue Square, Bellevue, WA 98004, 

Established: 1999

Read In-depth Review

Seattle has a great secret weapon at its disposal. We always mention all of the advantages of buying from an online retailer. But what if you can actually walk into a showroom of one of the biggest online jewelry giants? That would give you the best of both worlds. 

Fortunately, Blue Nile has a showroom located in the Emerald city. They offer exceptional customer service and extremely competitive pricing, so its customers can make confident purchasing decisions.

There is a wide selection of stunning jewelry options available at Blue Nile that will fit every budget, can be ordered without delay, and provide a smooth, risk-free experience. 

Located on the first floor of Bellevue Square, If you live in Seattle or will be traveling there, we highly recommend making a stop at the Blue Nile Showroom – it’s one of the best jewelry stores in Seattle by a mile! 

Their showroom is a great way to see their jewelry in person if you’re thinking of buying but hesitant to shop online – a perfect combination, really. Don’t forget to schedule an engagement ring consultation, jewelry consultation, or jewelry service appointment! 

2. Brilliant Earth – Best for Sustainable Shopping

Brilliant Earth

Location: 2651 NE 46th St, Seattle, WA 98105

Established: 2005

Read In-depth Review

Having failed to find a diamond engagement ring ethically sourced, Beth Gerstein and Eric Grossberg founded Brilliant Earth. Predominantly an online business model, Brilliant Earth has a select few brick-and-mortar showrooms in modern locations. 

University Village is an open-air lifestyle destination that features local boutiques, signature retailers, and an eclectic collection of restaurants. It’s also home to Brilliant Earth’s Seattle showroom, and it fits in seamlessly. 

If you’re hesitant about shopping online, with Brilliant Earth, you can schedule a personalized consultation for ethically sourced fine jewelry you’re sure to treasure. In a fun, stress-free atmosphere, you can learn about the 4Cs, precious metals, ethical diamonds, and their commitment to more eco-conscious practices. 

A beautiful example of elegance and social conscience, lab-grown diamonds from Brilliant Earth appeal to those seeking ethical purchases.

You’ll find this jewelry store in Seattle to be an eco-friendly alternative or a great place to shop if you’re interested in the benefits of diamonds without breaking the bank.

Use PriceScope's easy-to-navigate site to steer clear of dishonesty and bad deals in the Big D. Using our user-friendly forums and experts, you'll find the best loose diamonds at the best prices.]

3. Crane Jewelers – Best for Unique Custom Designs

Crane Jewelers

Location: 1326 5th Avenue Ste 707 In the Skinner Building, Seattle, WA 981011

Established: 2005

Crane Jewelers offers an impressive collection of custom-designed, antique, and international art pieces. The owner, Kevin Crane, specializes in custom design with thirty-five years of experience as a goldsmith, platinum smith, and stone setter. 

One of Seattle’s best jewelry stores for unique, personal jewelry pieces, it’s located in the historic Skinner Building. Available by appointment only, it does feel rather intimate and exclusive. 

In 1923, Arthur Gunderson opened his jewelry business in the Pacific Northwest, quickly becoming one of the region’s most trusted jewelers. A jewelry craftsman and designer, Philip Monroe joined him in 1965, eventually becoming his artistic heir, resulting in the purchase of the store in 1977.

Exhibitions of his work have been held in North America, Germany, Italy and Japan, and his work is represented in international collections. In Seattle, they are true experts in jewelry repair and antique restoration.

Looking for diamonds in the Emerald City? Compare prices, quality and long-term benefits presented by PriceScope's short list of vetted diamond vendors, including Whiteflash, Blue Nile, and James Allen

The select brands offered by our vetted vendors like Whiteflash A CUT ABOVE®, Astor by Blue Nile™, and JamesAllen.com True Hearts™ are displays of diamonds with superior cut quality.

4. Shane Co – Best Traditional Jewelry Store

Shane Co.

Location: 18833 28th Ave W, Lynnwood, WA 98036

Established: 2005

Read In-depth Review

It is impossible to miss Shane Co if you are shopping north of Seattle. Shane Co has a solid reputation as an established, family-run business in the diamond jewelry industry. As trends evolve, they have continued to update their business model with sleek branding, catchy radio ads from founder Tom Shane, and overall ‘luxury’ appeal. 

Shane Co. offers a wide array of jewelry products and has an extensive jewelry history. In every sense, Shane Co is a traditional jewelry store. The diamonds of Shane Co, however, are not always up to the challenge of quality versus quantity.

Their settings and styles definitely tend to veer heavily toward the ‘safe zone’. The Shane Co collections will nevertheless provide traditional brides with a well-finished, classic ring. In terms of style and standard, it’s what you’d expect from an established jeweler, although be aware the price is a little steep! 

Still, it’s a great jewelry store in Seattle if you’re looking for some traditionality but don’t mind paying a premium.

A diamond purchase should be exciting and easy if you have the right information, images, and certifications.

Top-tier laboratories grade all diamonds sold by Blue Nile, Whiteflash, Brilliant Earth, and James Allen. To ensure the accuracy of their diamonds, they also employ in-house gemologists.

5. Isadoras Antique Jewelry – Best for Antique Jewelry Pieces

Isadoras Antique Jewelry

Location: 1601 1st Ave, Seattle, WA 98101

Established: 1979 

The most extensive collection of antique jewelry in Seattle can be found at Isadoras.

Owner and operator Laura Dalesandro maintains Isadoras in Seattle Washington’s historic Pike Place Market. Together with her daughter Elizabeth, they travel the world in search of jewelry pieces that are antique, beautiful, handcrafted, and unique. 

Unlike many antique jewelry purveyors who carry both authentic and replica pieces, Isadoras exclusively sells vintage or antique jewelry. Every piece of jewelry in the Isadoras’ heirloom collection is handpicked by them!

It’s truly like an Alladin’s cave, making it one of the best jewelry stores in Seattle for picking up an eclectic piece steeped in history. 

The cut and clarity of vintage gems not for you? PriceScope's easy-to-navigate site, you control all specifications to find the diamond that meets your needs and dreams.

6. Pandora – Best Affordable Jewelry


Location: 517 Pine St, Seattle, WA 98101

Established: 1982

When it comes to shopping for jewelry in Seattle, Pandora Jewelry is a must-visit for value. It’s the perfect place for anyone looking for a great jewelry deal, due to its commitment to offering quality, affordable jewelry without sacrificing either style or quality.

Besides accessible pricepoint, customization is one of the main draws of Pandora Jewelry. You can create a truly unique piece of jewelry using a variety of charms and beads. Pandora makes it easy to customize your jewelry to match your style, whether you’re adding a charm to commemorate a special occasion or simply adding some personality.

In addition to Pandora’s famous charms and bracelets, the company’s rings, earrings, and necklaces are also stunning and versatile. A skilled team hand-sets each stone, making it quite unique in today’s mass-market environment. 

In conclusion, if you’re in Seattle and looking for the perfect piece of affordable jewelry to gift, Pandora Jewelry is the place to go. 

With its wide product range, experienced staff, in-store promotions, convenient locations, and online shopping options, Pandora has everything you need to find the perfect piece of reasonably priced jewelry. While you may be able to find a Pandora Jewelry store closer to home, it’s always worth checking out.

7. Tiffany & Co. – Best Luxury Experience 

Tiffany & Co.

Location: 600 Pine Street, Seattle, WA 98101

Established: 1837

Read In-depth Review

Tiffany & Co is a luxury jewelry brand that has been synonymous with style, elegance, and quality for over 170 years. If you’re in Seattle and looking for the ultimate shopping experience, then look no further than Tiffany & Co.

Tiffany & Co is known for its high-quality jewelry, made from the finest materials such as precious metals, diamonds, and gemstones. The brand has a long-standing commitment to Due to their heritage, quality of their materials, and craftsmanship, their jewelry is so highly sought after. With Tiffany & Co, you are investing in a piece of jewelry that lasts for a lifetime.

There is nothing more timeless than Tiffany & Co designs. There is no doubt that each piece of jewelry, whether it’s from the timeless Tiffany T collection or the classic Atlas® line, will remain as beautiful in ten years, twenty years, or fifty years from now as it does today.  

If you want to experience Tiffany’s for yourself, we won’t hold you back. An unforgettable experience awaits you at Tiffany & Co in Seattle. 

In most cases, these luxury stores justify their price by offering luxury experiences, which is why you might as well indulge in them. In spite of the inconvenience of trudging to a brick-and-mortar store, it does add to the enjoyment of indulgence purchases.

At a fraction of the cost and just as high-quality, our vetted vendors like Whiteflash, Blue Nile, and James Allen offer superior diamonds and jewelry. Look into them if you're looking for more value for your money.

8. Seattle Diamonds – Best For Designer Settings

Seattle Diamonds

Location: 900 Lenora St W100, Seattle, WA 98121

Established: 1985

As a family-owned business since 1985, Seattle Diamonds has provided countless couples with personalized service and exceptional value and quality. You will find GIA-trained gemologists and professional jewelers on their staff who are passionate about providing the finest diamond necklaces, earrings, and wedding bands. 

Among the designer jewelry they carry are engagement rings and wedding bands from A Jaffa, Precision Set, Novell, and Simon G. 

In addition to browsing through their extensive selection, you can schedule an appointment with their professional and courteous staff to find the perfect wedding rings, necklaces, and earrings.

Looking for beautiful designer settings and diamonds aplenty? Consider Whiteflash A CUT ABOVE® Super Ideal Cut Diamonds paired with a setting from their extensive inventory of designers such as Tacori, Verragio, Simon G, Ritani, Danhov, Vatche, and Benchmark.

Which Seattle Jewelry Store is the Best?

Unlike many major cities, Seattle does not have a traditional diamond district. However, you can still find quality diamonds and jewelry there if you know what to look for. The city still has a number of reputable and experienced jewelers, who can offer excellent service and high-quality products.

In terms of whether buying diamonds and jewelry in Seattle is worth it, the answer really depends on your individual needs and preferences.

No doubt there’s a lot to see and do in Seattle, from the gorgeous greenery to the breathtaking backdrop of the city, but it may not be the best place to buy a diamond based on value for money. 

We always recommend online shopping at reputable retailers, like Whiteflash, Blue Nile, or James Allen – through our experience this is the best way to maximize your budget, time and resource. 

In recent years, purchasing diamonds and jewelry online has become increasingly popular and offers several advantages over traditional brick-and-mortar stores. One advantage is the convenience of being able to shop from the comfort of your own home, at any time of day or night. 

Online jewelers also often offer a wider selection of products and more competitive prices than traditional stores, as they have lower overhead costs. Additionally, many online jewelers provide detailed information and specifications about each product, so you can make an informed decision before making a purchase. A jeweler recommended by us will be able to meet your needs, whether you prefer to shop online or in person.

You won't have to step foot in Seattle to find your dream diamond with our highly reputable, vetted vendors.

If you are looking to purchase a diamond of the highest quality available, remember to check out Whiteflash, Blue Nile, or James Allen before making your next diamond purchase.

Scroll to Top