Pear Diamond Comparisom

[Andy101]

Hey guys recently been quoted for both diamonds and they both fall into the same price range
Halo setting
Which one do you recommend?


Carat Weight : 1.10 Shape: Pear Cut : Excellent Color : G Clarity : VS2 Depth : 62.5% Table : 59% Polish : Excellent Symmetry : Excellent Girdle : Slightly Thick - Thick Culet: None Fluorescence : None Measurements: 8.82x5.85x3.66

OR


Measurements
9.65 x 5.68 x 3.44 mm
Carat Weight
1.07 carat
Color Grade
D
Clarity Grade
VS2
PROPORTIONS

Depth
60.6 %
Table
60 %
Girdle
Medium to Thick, Faceted
Culet
None

FINISH

Polish
Very Good
Symmetry
Very Good
FLUORESCENCE

Fluorescence
Medium Blue
CLARITY CHARACTERISTICS

Clarity Characteristics
Twinning Wisp, Cloud, Needle, Indented Natural, Natural

 

[Andy101]

For the 1.10 CT did not see an image of the diamond
The 1.07 they had the diamond in store for me to see and it was eye clean. Just stoll not sure about dimensions.
What are your opinions?

Thanks all

 

[Andy101]

Thanks for your fast reply! Appreciate your opinion for the 1.07 the report also stated

COMMENTS

Additional twinning wisps, pinpoints and surface graining are not shown.

If this means anything, I'll def's contact you about your site too!

Thanks

 

[Andy101]

Forgot to mention the 1.07 diamond.
The gia cert issue date was back in Nov 2014 .. is that an issue?

 

[tyty333]

Unfortunately numbers dont tell us enough about fancy cut stones (pears). We need up-close images and up-close videos to really be able
to tell what's going on.

 

[Andy101]

Sorry for that here are sone pictures I've managed to get

 

[tyty333]

Well, with only having that 1 picture to go by, I have to say that the faceting pattern on that pear looks pretty nice.
The rounded end has a large area of facets that look like they will return light nicely and there is no bow-tie.

 

[Andy101]

Hey thanks for your help tyty333
I managed to get an upclose picture of the 1.07

What do you all think

Thank you