Would like thoughts on 3rd replacement diamond....

[mrsj8610]

Ok, I'm back with 3rd replacement stone and unsure if I like it or not. I picked it out myself and now set I'm just not sure. It is VS1 G in color, GIA certed, with med flour. It has a depth of 62.9 % and table 54%, very good polish and good symmetry. Here are a few photos I snapped today in the car. What are your thoughts on how the stone looks? Oval diamonds are truly hard to shop for. I am able to exchange the stone, but am unsure if I should or not. According to the charts I see online, this diamond is considered excellent cut.

 

[Christina...]

What is it about the stone that you are unsure of? In the photos it looks like it has a significant bow tie, is that what you see when you look at? Did you inquire about that when you were considering the stone? Do you think it's the shape that you're unhappy with?