Would like opinions on this diamond... 1.02 round

[amanda1266]

Would like to get your opinion on this diamond:

1.02 Round
G color
SI2 clarity, eye clean
Depth 62.6 (is this too high?)
Table 56
Polish/Sym: Excellent
Medium Blue Fluor
HCA score 1.8 (scored Excellent in light return and fire, Very good in the other two, is that a problem?)

Please tell me if this is a good diamond. The price is $4593.

I'm concerned with the HCA score at 1.8. Another diamond I am considering has a 1.1 score and Excellent in all 4 categories. However, that diamond is smaller, so I would much prefer this one.

Also concerned with the depth. Is it too much?

Thanks!

 

[amanda1266]

Here is the link for your reference:
http://www.bluenile.com/round-diamo...ty_LD02997966?keyword_search_value=LD02997966

 

[Sakuracherry]

I've been told to stay under 62.4%, but it shouldn't be a big problem. Do you have pictures of the diamond? I think the stone is a great value if eye-clean.