Who wants to compare some stones (looking for pair for earrings/studs)?

[kev-man]

As I've mentioned in a couple of other threads I'm looking for a pair of diamonds for studs for my wife. I'd like to use WF due to their quality stones and stellar reputation around here (this will be my first internet vendor diamond purchase). I've posted a bunch of pairs that I'm considering. I think these all are decent matches (though I'm certainly no expert) and would love people's comments from around here. I've posted them in order of preference so if you don't have much time please check the early ones rather than the later ones. If you could post your preferred letter and which ones you looked at (I realize many won't have time to look at them all) I'd really appreciate it. You can click on the choice names to see the reports.

Thanks to everybody around here for all of their invaluable thoughts and advice.

---------------------------------------------------------------
Choice A (Click for Reports)
Shape --- ACA H&A , ACA H&A
Carat --- 0.735 , 0.731
Color --- F , F
Clarity --- SI1 , SI1
Mmts --- 5.75-5.78X3.56 , 5.80-5.82X3.54
Table % --- 56.8 , 57.1
Depth % --- 61.8 , 60.9
Polish --- Ideal , Ideal
Sym --- Ideal , Ideal
Gir --- TN to Sl TK , TN to M Faceted
Cul --- Pointed , Pointed
Fluor --- Negligible , Negligible
Cert --- AGS , AGS
Price --- $3,296.00 , $3,296.00
Crown A --- 34.7 , 34.9
Pav A --- 40.7 , 40.7
HCA --- 1.2 , 1.2


Choice B (Click for Reports)
Shape --- ACA H&A , ACA H&A
Carat --- 0.72 , 0.723
Color --- F , E
Clarity --- SI1 , SI1
Mmts --- 5.79-5.82X3.53 , 5.74-5.76X3.55
Table % --- 56.9 , 56.8
Depth % --- 60.8 , 61.7
Polish --- Ideal , Ideal
Sym --- Ideal , Ideal
Gir --- TN to M Faceted , TN to M Faceted
Cul --- Pointed , Pointed
Fluor --- Negligible , Negligible
Cert --- AGS , AGS
Price --- $3,236.00 , $3,467.00
Crown Ang --- 34.6 , 34.7
Pav Ang --- 40.7 , 40.7
HCA --- 1 , 1.1


Choice C (Click for Reports)
Shape --- ACA H&A , ACA H&A
Carat --- 0.752 , 0.752
Color --- F , F
Clarity --- SI1 , VS1
Mmts --- 5.81-5.84X3.60 , 5.82-5.84X3.61
Table % --- 55.5 , 56.7
Depth % --- 61.8 , 62
Polish --- Ideal , Ideal
Sym --- Ideal , Ideal
Gir --- TN to M Faceted , TN to M Faceted
Cul --- Pointed , Pointed
Fluor --- Negligible , Negligible
Cert --- AGS , AGS
Price --- $3,387.00 , $4,055.00
Crown Ang --- 34.6 , 34.7
Pav Ang --- 40.7 , 40.9
HCA --- 1.1 , 1.8

Choice D (Click for Reports)
Shape --- ACA H&A , ACA H&A
Carat --- 0.71 , 0.71
Color --- H , G
Clarity --- VVS2 , VS1
Mmts --- 5.74-5.78X3.53 , 5.71-5.76X3.51
Table % --- 55 , 56.6
Depth % --- 61.4 , 61.3
Polish --- Ideal , Ideal
Sym --- Ideal , Ideal
Gir --- TN to M Faceted , TN to M Faceted
Cul --- Pointed , Pointed
Fluor --- Negligible , Negligible
Cert --- AGS , AGS
Price --- $3,355.00 , $3,571.00
Crown Ang --- 34.9 , 34.8
Pav Ang --- 40.7 , 40.6
HCA --- 1.1 , 0.8


Choice E (Click for Reports)
Shape --- ACA H&A , ACA H&A
Carat --- 0.563 , 0.566
Color --- G , F
Clarity --- VS2 , VVS2
Mmts --- 5.26-5.29X3.26 , 5.36-5.38X3.28
Table % --- 56.8 , 54.8
Depth % --- 61.8 , 61.2
Polish --- Ideal , Ideal
Sym --- Ideal , Ideal
Gir --- TN to SL THK Faceted , TN Faceted
Cul --- Pointed , Pointed
Fluor --- Negligible , Negligible
Cert --- AGS , AGS
Price --- $1,940.00 , $2,850.00
Crown Ang --- 34.6 , 34.5
Pav Ang --- 40.8 , 40.9
HCA --- 1.5 , 1.5



Choice F (Click for Reports)
Shape --- ACA H&A , ACA H&A
Carat --- 0.523 , 0.527
Color --- F , F
Clarity --- VVS2 , VVS2
Mmts --- 5.20-5.23X3.18 , 5.22-5.24X3.20
Table % --- 56.5 , 55
Depth % --- 61 , 61.2
Polish --- Ideal , Ideal
Sym --- Ideal , Ideal
Gir --- TN to M Faceted , TN Faceted
Cul --- Pointed , Pointed
Fluor --- Negligible , Negligible
Cert --- AGS , AGS
Price --- $2,646.00 , $2,646.00
Crown Ang --- 34.8 , 34.7
Pav Ang --- 40.8 , 40.7
HCA --- 1.4 , 1


Thanks again

 

[strmrdr]

1st set wins bling for the buck out of the .7x crowd...
As long as both are eyecleean go for it.,,,,