Which would you pick?

[wowabuds]

Hi, I've been lurking here for the past couple days trying to learn about idealscope and ASET images, some of you have a wealth of knowledge.. Being an amateur, I would really appreciate some input in the 3 stones I am considering! Which would you pick and why? Thanks

They are the same color, VS2, price difference of $200




From ACA
I called in about the inclusion in the table, the rep (whiteflash) said it was eye clean, only to be seen with a 10x loupe.






From expert selection




From expert selection

 

[OECsareforLovers]

My guess is you aren't getting any bites because you didn't provide measurements and angles. Post those and more will chime in!

 

[luvdajules]

are they all the same size? If so, I'll take the ACA if it's only $200 more. My guess is that the ES is slightly bigger with the same color and clarity, maybe 0.2 mm bigger? that's visible, so I'd go that direction if that one is $200 more.

 

[drk14]

My pick would be the middle one, based primarily on gut feeling. Dunno, it seems to have a bit more optical symmetry than the others, and is possibly also slightly brighter under the table (per IS images).

 

[Gypsy]

In order of preference #2, #1, #3.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I also would not choose just based on the pictures. I want to know the diameter measurements. All are obviously ideal cut and probably would look almost identical. Just from the images I do not care for that inclusion in #1 so I probably would not pick it due to it being in the center. Now I'd need the diameter measurements to choose.