Which wedding band would you choose?

[Erinleigh]

I'm having a difficult time deciding which wedding band I should go with! I'm a big fan of bands that aren't super matchy with the e-ring, so I'm debating between two styles.
My e-ring (in platinum):

A) Marquise-shaped eternity band (would be in platinum)

B) A band that is closer to the shape of my e-ring (but would be done in rose gold for contrast), and could possibly be stacked later on?

Which would you choose? Would you do something different than either of these?

 

[KikiD]

Definately the marquise band! I think that would look really interesting and not too matchy

 

[diamondbuggy]

I love the marquise band! Especially since you said you don't like it too matchy.

 

[Clairitek]

Theyre both really pretty but I would go for the marquise band if you don't want anything that matches perfectly with your engagement ring!

 

[slg47]

I also like the marquise band

but I have to admit because this thread is in BWW and not RT, I thought you were talking about musical bands...why...I'm not sure...it definitely says wedding band I guess music was on the brain or something!

 

[lulu66]

i agree w/everyone else...love the marquise. it's just a little different & interesting. your ering is gorg btw!

 

[IrisAccents]

Everyone beat me to the punch, but definitely the marquise! The long, sleek shapes will look so beautiful next to your *gorgeous* e-ring!

 

[Brown.Eyed.Girl]

Add me to the marquise team! It's unique but at the same time I think it would complement your ring perfectly!

 

[megumic]

B for sure - classier!

 

[AustenNut]

I vote marquise.

 

[missydebby]

I love the marquise band! Especially since you said you don't like it too matchy.

ditto!

 

[meresal]

Theyre both really pretty but I would go for the marquise band if you don't want anything that matches perfectly with your engagement ring!

+1. My band is very similar to the second one you posted, and I got it b/c I wanted to match my ering band. If you don't like "matchy" then I think the choice is definitely clear.

Is there something about the second one that you love? Why is the decision hard if you don't like "matchy"?

 

[Dreamer_D]

Marquise. I think the rose gold and the contrast could be something you regret down the road as it is such a distinctive look that it would be hard to work with if you taste changes.

 

[ts44]

I might have a solution for you on the rose gold front - I love rose gold but have a platinum e-ring like you, but it was important to my husband and I that our wedding bands matched, so we each got plain milgrained platinum wedding bands. To satisfy my rose gold craving, I got a rose gold rope band from Sally at Heart of Water Jewels on Etsy to use as a spacer band between my wedding ring and my e-ring, because they really don't match at all. Forgive the super shady cell phone picture:



That way my wedding band is something I'll wear forever, but down the line if I ever get tired of the rose gold I can just swap out the little spacer for something else. For size reference, my wedding band is 3mm wide.

 

[motownmama]

I like the 2nd band

 

[OUpearlgirl]

I'd go with the marquise band as well. It's gorgeous!