Which stone sounds better??

[sbingus]

Can you all please tell me which stone in your opinion sounds better? pros and cons of each. also keep in mind that they are priced almost identical if that helps! thanks so much for your feedback

stone A
here is the info of the GIA report:
emerald cut
10.51 x 8.11 x 5.71
4.66 carat
depth 70.4%
table 60%
girdle slight thick to thick
cutlet none
polish good
symmetry good
clarity vvs2
color I
l:w ratio 1.30
fluorescence medium blue

stone b
GIA
4.37 carat
Emerald cut
I color
vs1 clarity
polish very good
symmetry good
flour. none
table 55%
depth 67.5%
girdle thin-slighty thick
l:w ration 1.42

 

[sbingus]

oh forgot to add the measurements for stone b. here lets try again..

stone A
here is the info of the GIA report:
emerald cut
10.51 x 8.11 x 5.71
4.66 carat
depth 70.4%
table 60%
girdle slight thick to thick
cutlet none
polish good
symmetry good
clarity vvs2
color I
l:w ratio 1.30
fluorescence medium blue

stone b
GIA
4.37 carat
11.28x7.94x5.35
Emerald cut
I color
vs1 clarity
polish very good
symmetry good
flour. none
table 55%
depth 67.5%
girdle thin-slighty thick
l:w ration 1.42

 

[Lorelei]

Photos are really needed and preferably an ASET image of each diamond, can you get those?