Which setting?

[brightstone]

I think we have pretty much decided on our setting, but there are two others that are similar by the same designer, and I wanted to know what your opinions were on each/the other two. I will post pics of the one we are proabably going with, then pics of the other two. It''s tough because I only was able to try on the one (in the first pic) and then when I went back with my boyfriend it had sold already, so he''s hasn''t seen any of them and I have only seen one. So, we''ll be ordering sight unseen, essentially. Any opinions on the three, ie. which you like best (especially of the two that are more simple...they are $2500 less expensive, so we''ll need to go with one of those)?

Thank you!

 

[brightstone]

Second one..

 

[brightstone]

third one....

 

[arjunajane]

Brightstone, I do not want to rain on you parade at all, but personally I would be concerned with the side stones falling out from these settings?
Have you discussed this possibility with the jeweller?
Aside from that, I like the second one the best.

 

[motownmama]

prefer the second one - good luck!

 

[goobear78]

I also prefer the second one. Good luck choosing, they are all beautiful!

 

[HariSeldon]

i vote the first one with the prongs of the second!