Which One?

[cute330xigrl]

Both are eye-clean H SI1 ''s RB''s

stone#1
Measurement - 7.39-7.44x4.57
Weight - 1.52
Depth - 61.9%
Table - 56%
Girdle - Thin-Med
Culet - None
Polish - Ex.
Sym - Ex.
Flour - None

stone#2
Measurement - 7.45-7.52x4.52
Weight - 1.52
Depth - 60.4%
Table - 59%
Girdle - Thin-Med
Culet - None
Polish - VG
Sym - VG
Flour - None

In person , stone#2 appeared to be a stronger H.

Pls let me know which one you''d choose and why. Thx Much!!!

 

[cute330xigrl]

^^bump. come on Jedi''s!

 

[fire&ice]

Are these GIA? Have you seen them both to compare? What are the prices? Do you have crown or pavillion angles?

edited to add: Are they from the same vendor - i.e. comparing same services?

 

[aljdewey]

I''d really want to know crown/pavilion angles...from the information here, it''s really a toss-up.

The rest of the information would likely help.

 

[MaybeDayze]

Are you upgrading your I VVS1 set in that amazing Leon Mege?

 

[DolceVita]

Both look great, and if both are GIAs it's a tough decision. Perhaps the SI1 is different between them? If not, i'd really go with what "personally" works for you, what you feel better about. If you don't want to go that way, take the stronger H.

 

[JohnQuixote]

Without crown/pavilion angles or IS/ASET reflector images I'd need to see them in person to make a fair judgement on performance.

Since you have seen them in person you're in a position to make a better decision than anyone else.

 

[cute330xigrl]

Date: 6/14/2005 11:35:36 AM
Author: MarLoRey
Are you upgrading your I VVS1 set in that amazing Leon Mege?

Haha, noooo. This was for a friend. Althoughhhhh, I did talk a lot to Leon about future projects.

Ahem, yes well.. back to my friend. Unfortunately I dont have crown&pav. angles. Both GIA certs. My friend favored stone#2 more. Thnx everyone for helping as much as u could.