Which one would you pick?

[mmmdoan]

Okay, so there are two stones. From my reading, one is borderline a "steep, deep" and one is a spready stone.

first one is 1.70 vs2 Gia xxx measures 7.63-7.67-4.75
depth 62.1
table 57
crown angle 35
pav angle 41
med faceted 3.5

My only concern is the depth. I had a 62.5 depth stone before and it looked small for weight. It really bothered me.

the second stone is 1.72 vs2 Gia xxx measures 7.75-7.77-4.65 (love those measurements)
depth 60
table 59
crown angle 34.5
pav angle 40.6
med faceted 3.5

So from what I've read, the table is good for the first one, but the angles are a bit off and the second one has great angles but the 59 % table might lack fire.

which one would you choose if you had to choose one. I'm gravitating towards the spready stone.

Thanks for any response!

 

[mmmdoan]

Also the the one I had with 62.5 depth and 56 table had great fire and performed amazing under spot lighting and grocery store lighting but kind of boring under lack of light. It had great angles too crown 33.5 and pav 40.8. Scored excelent with hca.

The hca score for the two stones above is 2.4 and 1.1 respectively. The second one scored excellent in all areas.

 

[tyty333]

Can you get idealscope images for these stones?