which one is a better deal?

[swl]

Hi ladies, as i am playing with the "build your own ring" websites, I stumble-upon these two options, I would like to hear your opinions

Both are white gold 5 stone rings:

1) 1.8 ctw- 3 Fs and 2 Gs-SI1-GIA 3 Ex- all stones score within 1.5 in the cut adviser- $3400

2) 2.09 ctw - All D color- SI1- AGSL Ideal- all stones score within 1.5 in the cut adviser- $4816

do you think there will be a noticeable big difference between finger coverage? which one do you think it''s a better deal? assuming they are all well cut

 

[chrono]

That''s quite a tidy sum to see very little difference in size. Assuming the cut is comparable, I''d take the less expensive option.

 

[tyty333]

Date: 6/23/2009 12:39:59 AM
Author: Chrono
That''s quite a tidy sum to see very little difference in size. Assuming the cut is comparable, I''d take the less expensive option.

I agree...I would go with the $3400 combination (if all the stones are well cut). There is going to be plenty
of bling either way!!! (I have a .8 ctw 5 stone for a wedding band and it gives me lots of bling...add another
carat to it and Wow...it will be a real show stopper!)

 

[D&T]

thritto to the others above!

 

[swl]

anyone else?