Which one? 1.58 G VS2 $14k or 1.6 F VS2 $15k

[engago]

1.6 F VS2 $15k
7.48mm

table 56.0
depth 61.9
crown angle 34.5
pav angle 40.6


or


1.58 G VS2 $14k (note the width of the diamond is bigger)
7.59mm

table 59.0
depth 59.6
crown angle 33.5
pav angle 40.8


Why is the 1.58 so cheap compared to the others? Is it because it's considered a 60/60 stone (although this one is a 59/59)?

 

[luvdajules]

Hi OP, between the 2, the first one looks to be the better bet and it's an F color. Are these GIA certified? You are correct, the second would be considered and priced as a 60/60 and has a bit of a shallow crown and I wouldn't think it's as good as the first. Get an ASET of the first or have it done by an appraiser during your return window.