Which of these 5 rocks should I buy tomorrow morning?

[rockscared]

You guys are the experts. Help me take the plunge! I'm a relative newb at this.

Here are the 5 rocks I'm thinking of buying tomorrow morning, in order of preference.

Carat    Color    Clarity    HCA    $
1.50     F        VS1        1.6    $16,119
1.46     E        VS1        1.9    $16,030
1.45     E        VS1        1.8    $16,169
1.43     E        VS1        1.4    $16,414 (Why so much more?)
1.41     F        VVS2       1.9    $16,013

(All Cuts = Excellent, Flourescence = None)

Which one should I buy? Which ones should I not buy? They're all roughly the same price.

More details...
Rock 1.50, HCA=1.6


Rock 1.46, HCA=1.9


Rock 1.45, HCA=1.8


Rock 1.43, HCA=1.4


Rock 1.41, HCA=1.6

Thank you so much, experts!​

 

[Gypsy]

Why such high color and clarity?

They are all lovely. Seriously. There is no bad choice (although IMO spending money you don't have to on clarity is a bad choice).

You would have to get idealscopes and post them for us to be able to tell you more.

 

[rockscared]

Why such high color and clarity?

They are all lovely. Seriously. There is no bad choice (although IMO spending money you don't have to on clarity is a bad choice).

You would have to get idealscopes and post them for us to be able to tell you more.

I've read you need bionic eyes to see flaws in VS1. Is that the same for VS2?

 

[tyty333]

Are these all at the same place? Can you have the gemologist review 3 or so of them and give you an opinion on what they see.
Tough to narrow them down when they all pretty much have the same numbers/stats.

 

[sdrz71]

These options all sound like they would be good choices but make sure what you can afford and begin with that.