Which is a better Pair PLEASE?

[newcomer]

Hello Everyone,
I need to finalize on a pair of earrings from the two sets below. Could you please provide your comments and suggestions on which is a better pair regardless of the price (differential is about $400).

Set 1: 0.795, 0.787, Triple Ideal 0, AGS
Set 2: 0.840, 0.800, EX, EX, GIA

I do not have the pav/crown specs for the Set 2.

Aldjewey, I''d appreciate it if you could provide your thoughts.

Thank you and appreciate your assistance.*********************************************
Cts .795 .787 .840 .80
Lab AGS AGS GIA GIA
Shp RD RD RD RD
Clr E F F F
Clar VS2 VS1 VS1 VS1
Dep 60.3 60.7 61.9 61.0
Tbl 57 56 55 56
Dim 6.03x6.05 6.00x6.02 6.06x6.08 6.01x6.03
Flour None None None None
Crown 34.9 35.0
Pav% 42.70 43.10
Pav Deg 40.6 40.9
Girdle 1.0%-1.5% .7%-1.5%
NOTE- AGS-IDEAL 0 AGS-IDEAL 0 X,X X,X

 

[hoorray]

I like # 2 with #4. (I know that probably wasn't in your plans...)

They are the best matching in diameter, the same color, the same table size, and the same clarity (although as long is they are eye-clean, that doesn't matter)! Ctw doesn't matter for matching -- what matters is diameter.

I'm a stickler about matching diameters, with color as my second criteria, and table third, so that's my pick, having just gone through this exercise myself.

However, I would get the angles on #3&4 to make sure they are up to par. Without them, you can't be sure what you are looking at.