Which hoop is the better choice? Very confused

[Dhana]

I am very undecided but have wanted a lab diamond hoop for a long time
I have settled on 2 choices
1) lab diamond hoop from Etsy khamkar diamonds

https://www.etsy.com/listing/1563226664/round-lab-grown-diamond-earrings18-k?click_key=ec6aea6b79d66a765ec35cae00cb62baa6e3f7dd%3A1563226664&click_sum=0741c156&ref=shop_home_active_2&pro=1&frs=1&sts=1&variation0=3896863014

2) my second choice is this one from Elizabeth jewellery inc

14Kt Gold 3 Ct Lab Grown Diamond Huggie Hoop Earrings

These are beautiful Lab Grown Diamonds set in Solid 14Kt Gold that can be worn for any occasion. You can choose if you want it in White Gold or Yellow Gold. The diamonds sparkle beautifully.We have a lot of beautiful jewelry with natural diamonds. If any listing states "diamond" then it is a...

elizabethjewelrydesigns.com

I am struggling because while i love the design from khamkar - and I plan to wear it daily I wonder if the stones will be less secure when compared to the one on Elizabeth - this has a lock as well and setting seems nice - I don’t think the stone will fall off ..
also is it a better value than the one in Etsy ? I am confused - also probably heavier .
What do others think ?

 

[Dhana]

@pancake any thoughts

 

[pancake]

@pancake any thoughts

The stones in the Elizabeth setting are double the weight of the Khamkar ones - so the stones are a fair bit bigger, the hoop will be bigger, and it's a different look.

As far as the setting itself goes I much prefer the Khamkar one because the baskets are open. I did mention this when I originally posted my pair - in the photos on the listing it shows a U prong setting but in reality (and in the CADs I was provided) there is a bar under the girdle. The settings are very secure - I have worn the for over a month at a time without removing them at all and no concerns.

 

[ksage92]

Not to highjack, but @pancake did you purchase the pair linked above? TY

 

[pancake]

Not to highjack, but @pancake did you purchase the pair linked above? TY

I bought the Khamkar pair - I have posted close-ups in one of the other threads