Which diamond would you pick?

[Peanut1234]

Choice #1---1.3 D VS1 with some internal and surface graining; table size 55; crown angle 34; pav angle 40.8; pav depth 43; star length 55; lower half length 75; girdle medium to slightly thick 3.5%; total depth 61.8; no cutlet; no fluorescence; crown height 15.5

Choice #2--1.61 F VS2 with some clouds, feather, needle; table size 55; crown angle 35; pav angle 40.6; star length 50; lower half length 80; girdle thin to medium 3.0%; total depth 61.6; no cutlet; no flurorescence; crown height 15.5

Both excellent cut, polish, and symmetry

Which one would you pick?

 

[Ellen]

Hi peanut,

We need all the info on the diamond to make any kind of guess.

 

[Peanut1234]

Thanks, Ellen. Just added the additional information.

 

[Ellen]

Welcome!

Ok, both have potential, but going on this onfo alone, I would prefer #1.

 

[Peanut1234]

Hi Ellen,

Can you tell me why you would pick #1? Thanks!

 

[stone-cold11]

#2. Same price?

 

[Ellen]

I prefer the crown and pavilion angles. They are really important to a stones performance, and these are in a "safer" range. If we had a Helium report, I might change my mind. Again, this is just going on whaty we have here.

 

[sazza]

I''m leaning towards #2. They both do well on the HCA (#1 is 1 and #2 is . so I''d go with the bigger stone since I personally would not be able to see the difference in color between F and D.