Which diamond would you choose?

[col83]

Hi
This is my first post but i have being reading this forum for a long time. thanks for all your knowledge.
I have narrowed it down to these 3stones.
Which diamond do you think would give the best sparkle?
All 3diamonds are GIA certified.

1)
0.62, E colour, Si1 clarity, excellent polish, very good symmetry , depth 61.9%, table 54%, florescence none price $1689 cad

2)
0.60, Ecolour Si1 clarity, excellent polish, excellent symmetry, depth 61.8%, table 56%, florescence none price $1788 cad

3) 0.58, F colour, VS2 clarity, excellent polish, excellent symmetry, depth 60.3%, table 61%, flourscence faint. $1787 cad

Thanks for you help in advance
Col83

 

[Dreamer_D]

Can you post the crown and pavilion angles of the diamonds, from the certs? Thanks.

 

[col83]

Here is the crown and pavilion details for the 3 stones.

1)crown is 34 and pavilion angle is 40.8

2)crown is 34.5 and pavilion angles 40.8

3)crown is 33 and pavilion angles is 41.6

Thanks again
col83

 

[yssie]

#1 is not the right pav

 

[yssie]

prefer 2, or 1 if pav is 40.6-41 maybe 41.2


can you get ISs?

 

[col83]

Thanks yssie, I corrected no 1s pavilion it was 40.8.

What is ISs? Sorry i am still new to this!

 

[Dreamer_D]

I like number 2 from the numbers, followed by 1.

A Ideal Scope is a tool that will help you assess cut quality. https://www.pricescope.com/idealscope_indx.asp You can buy your own.

Or else, can you see the diamond in person? Take them into lots of different lighting environments and see which of the first two you like better.

 

[stone-cold11]

ditto.

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 3/10/2010 11:26:11 PM
Author:col83
Hi
This is my first post but i have being reading this forum for a long time. thanks for all your knowledge.
I have narrowed it down to these 3stones.
Which diamond do you think would give the best sparkle?
All 3diamonds are GIA certified.

1)
0.62, E colour, Si1 clarity, excellent polish, very good symmetry , depth 61.9%, table 54%, florescence none price $1689 cad

2)
0.60, Ecolour Si1 clarity, excellent polish, excellent symmetry, depth 61.8%, table 56%, florescence none price $1788 cad

3) 0.58, F colour, VS2 clarity, excellent polish, excellent symmetry, depth 60.3%, table 61%, flourscence faint. $1787 cad

Thanks for you help in advance
Col83

Hi Col

Also with the SI clarity grades, can you check what the grade making inclusions are please such as feathers, clouds etc?

 

[col83]

Thanks for your help, I am buying online so I cannot see the diamond before I choose one.
The inclusion information is.

1)cloud finish
2)feather finish
3)crystal cloud finish.