Which diamond to choose??? Need your advice please

[DingDing]

I''m picking between three diamonds and cannot decide which one is better. Can someone give me their opinions and whether or not eithe of these are good buys? Thanks


Diamond 1: Princess cut
Price: 61800
Carat Weight :3.33
Cut: Excellent
Color :G
Clarity : VS1
Depth :68.5
Table :69
Polish :excellent
Symmetry :excellent
Girdle :TN-M
Culet :None
Fluorescence : Faint Blue
Ratio :1.03
Measurements :8.60x8.35x5.72

Diamond 2: Princess cut
Price: 61195
Carat Weight :3.53
Cut: Excellent
Color :F
Clarity : VS2
Depth :71.4
Table :73
Polish : Very good
Symmetry :Excellent
Girdle :M- STK
Culet :None
Fluorescence : None
Ratio :1.03
Measurements :8.54x8.31x5.93

Diamond 3: Princess cut
Price: 62765
Carat Weight :3.70
Cut: Excellent
Color :G
Clarity : VS2
Depth :71.4
Table :71
Polish :Excellent
Symmetry :Very good
Girdle :VTN-M
Culet :None
Fluorescence : None
Ratio :1.02
Measurements :8.64x8.47x6.05

 

[tyty333]

Hi DD,
You cant pick princess cuts by the numbers. Do you have pictures (up close) of the stones you can post? Any aset image
by any chance? Post those too. Have you seen these stones in person? Have you seen them side-by-side?

We usually look for the table to be smaller than the depth. Yours are all about the same as the depth. I personally like
small tables.

tyty

 

[DingDing]

Sorry, tyty333, I don't have any pics, I found those diamonds online. I think I should call them to get the pics, but I don't think they have it, cause I saw the same stone from a few different online store.

 

[Amys Bling]

Like TY said- there is no way to know if the cut and performance of a princess cut (any fancy cut) is good without images and ASET. Otherwise you are just trusting their arbitrary grading they put on the princess cut- and for that kind of money I would want to KNOW for a fact that the stone is a great performer with tremendous sparkle and brillance.

Also- for a princess cut stone, I would say away from Very Thin Girdle as princess cut stones can chip on the girdle.