which diamond should I buy???

[ringbling17]

hi everyone,
well, again I can''t decide which one to choose- so here goes-
1.25 F vs2 AGS A Cut Above H&A
6.99x7.00x4.24
t-57.7
d-60.6
crown angle- 34.9
pavillion angle- 40.9
girdle-1.0-1.4
symmetry and polish- ID/ID
price- $9234
HCA score- 1.5
OR
1.27 E vs1
7.05x7.07x4.28
t- 54
d- 60.6
crown angle- 34.4
pavillion angle- 40.7
symmetry and polish- ID/ID
price- $9924
HCA score- 0.7
which one would you choose?
thanks in advance!