Which combo looks better for a 3-stone ring?

[kenny]

I'm trying to pick a blue FCD to go with my Green and Purple Pink.

Which combination looks better for a 3-stone ring?
Why?


.
.
.
.
.
.

 

[slg47]

I prefer the first one. it is hard to tell with pics of course, but to me the color saturation looks more even across the first three, whereas in the second combination the blue one appears much less saturated. also, with the emerald cuts not being exactly the same size, I prefer the cushion so they are all different cuts.

what about the blue FCD you have? and that pear? any plans for those?

 

[kenny]

what about the blue FCD you have? and that pear? any plans for those?

No plans yet.

 

[Echidna]

I prefer the first one. it is hard to tell with pics of course, but to me the color saturation looks more even across the first three, whereas in the second combination the blue one appears much less saturated. also, with the emerald cuts not being exactly the same size, I prefer the cushion so they are all different cuts.

Agree 100%.

 

[susimoo]

I prefer the first one. it is hard to tell with pics of course, but to me the color saturation looks more even across the first three, whereas in the second combination the blue one appears much less saturated. also, with the emerald cuts not being exactly the same size, I prefer the cushion so they are all different cuts.

what about the blue FCD you have? and that pear? any plans for those?

What Sig47 said.

 

[isaku5]

The first combo for the reasons stated above, but also #1 is just more pleasing to the eye .

 

[kenny]

Well, I did it again.
I didn't put them it on hold first and now the first one is sold.
When will I learn?

Thanks all for your input.